Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Recommended Posts

Interesting to notice the difference between r5's and ehorn's charts in including the two containers from the 1040 to 1345 period in the down respectively up slower fractal container.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Market was kind... gives us signals that WMCN did NOT... lots of time to wash this one and mark it for debrief and review to find what one missed.

WNMCN.png.fabc7bc08d49b26d5f83337a29c59782.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Market was kind... gives us signals that WMCN did NOT... lots of time to wash this one and mark it for debrief and review to find what one missed.

 

but... when the sequence is completed, there can be no mercy...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

These guys didn't do their MADA ... :)

Forums ›› Main ›› Trading ›› wtf was that?

05-28-10 10:13 AM

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Quote from Bob111:

 

Thank you!

nice timing..low volume, middle of the day..perfect for those "flashers" to screw you on spreads

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Everybody on CNBC and Fox Business angry about the timing. Everybody caught long!

 

Wrong psychology for the long weekend.

Forums ›› Main ›› Trading ›› Volume Spike

05-28-10 01:20 PM

 

WTF? ES just did 50M contracts in 30 min according to my chart.

 

Is this the end of session Globex auction or just a method to take out stops?

 

... Is this tradable at bid/offer?

 

What is this?

 

(edit: It happened 1545 - 1615 Eastern time)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A different way of seeing those "goats" when the pace slowed down and a finer fractal became visible.

 

Hi cnms2,

 

Thanks for posting the chart. If I read the chart correctly, the volume pane from 2:10 pm EST showed faster fractals gaussians and you had drawn maybe a fractal slower to capture the b2b.

 

I am still in the early stages of learning, and I would usually build from the smallest fractal up based on the gaussians to arrive at the price fractal. Would that be a correct approach ?

 

The pink channel container - was that drawn after PT3 at 3:35 pm and was it a WMCN anticipation ?

 

Thanks again for sharing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi cnms2,

 

Thanks for posting the chart. ...

A quick note: that was rs5's chart to which I added two annotations (in the highlighted areas), for the sake of discussion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A quick note: that was rs5's chart to which I added two annotations (in the highlighted areas), for the sake of discussion.

 

I was actually looking at the similarities and thought that both of you must be on almost exactly the same page in terms of logical thinking and visualization of the fractals and gaussians :o

 

Then this means perhaps rs5 would care to provide some comments on my questions.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Greetings emac, welcome to the thread.

 

I am still in the early stages of learning, and I would usually build from the smallest fractal up based on the gaussians to arrive at the price fractal. Would that be a correct approach ?

 

Yes, per earlier lessons in the thread. http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/34/price-volume-relationship-6320-30.html#post72196

 

The pink channel container - was that drawn after PT3

 

Yes, RTL is drawn after formation of P3. http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/f34/price-volume-relationship-6320.html

 

Happy MADA!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

New to this thread so please be patient.

 

My question is on any given day we are looking for completion of a volume sequence, in order to determine if a trend has completed. Since each day may be a continuation of a sequence and then completion, how common is it that one would see more then one or two completed volume sequences for an entire day?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I noticed that PT multistation trading terminal shows an extra little bar chart for the volume, at the bottom of the chart beneath every candle, which I find convenient, especially for scalpers.

 

But more interestingly is that ProTrader / PT multistation also shows a volume graph updating in real-time in the volume column of the watchlist for each instrument, stock, etc. - and you can easily sort that column.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Since each day may be a continuation of a sequence and then completion, how common is it that one would see more then one or two completed volume sequences for an entire day?

 

As a trader begins to learn how to thoroughly annotate a chart, one's mental calibration exists at a certain observational level. By bringing into the analysis the market's fractal nature, the learning trader begins to learn to see mulitple sequences complete nested within a larger orientation. Pace often determines how many fractals one has the ability to see. As a result, it is far more rare to see only one completed order of events on any given trading day. However, many individuals (just beginning the learning process) often have yet to develop the ability to see that which the market has provided.

 

Note the ES for today.

 

Moving forward from 9:55 (Eastern Time and Close of Bar), one can 'see' a number of fractals completing - some faster and some slower - as time progresses. Once a trader determines which fractal best mirrors their skill level and trading goals, then that trader simply 'waits' until said fractal moves through the order of events.

 

As an individual gains additional experience by reaching various 'knowledge plateaus' with respect to the learning process, what once seemed obscured or 'impossible' transitions to ordinary and mundane.

 

- Spydertrader

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
As a trader begins to learn how to thoroughly annotate a chart, one's mental calibration exists at a certain observational level. By bringing into the analysis the market's fractal nature, the learning trader begins to learn to see mulitple sequences complete nested within a larger orientation. Pace often determines how many fractals one has the ability to see. As a result, it is far more rare to see only one completed order of events on any given trading day. However, many individuals (just beginning the learning process) often have yet to develop the ability to see that which the market has provided.

 

Note the ES for today.

 

Moving forward from 9:55 (Eastern Time and Close of Bar), one can 'see' a number of fractals completing - some faster and some slower - as time progresses. Once a trader determines which fractal best mirrors their skill level and trading goals, then that trader simply 'waits' until said fractal moves through the order of events.

 

As an individual gains additional experience by reaching various 'knowledge plateaus' with respect to the learning process, what once seemed obscured or 'impossible' transitions to ordinary and mundane.

 

- Spydertrader

Thanks for the reply. I am curious as to how you developed your personal skill. Did you have a mentor at one time?

 

I would be very interested as to how you approach the market as a trader. It is one thing to annotate a chart, another to trade it in real time. Do you trade the intraday tapes, or are you looking more to postion for traverses, and channels, or all of the above?

 

Regards

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I am curious as to how you developed your personal skill. Did you have a mentor at one time?

 

About ten years ago, I traded stocks using nothing but Price Action as my guide. At that time, I focused on the SPY, DIA and QQQ as my trading vehicles of choice (Hence the username - Spydertrader). After stumbling across some posts on USENET by Jack Hershey, I felt something about his writings resonated with me - in that, I had seen something (in the markets ) which appeared to correspond to the information delineated within his posts. Although quite a number of individuals within the USENET Groups of MISC.INVEST.STOCKS and MISC.INVEST.FUTURES argued (vehemently) that his verbose contributions made no sense, I felt otherwise. At that point, I began my own journey (the vast majority of which I cronicled on the Elitetrader.com web site). However, Jack has always insisted I use the market as my guide.

 

I would be very interested as to how you approach the market as a trader. Do you trade the intraday tapes, or are you looking more to postion for traverses, and channels, or all of the above?

 

I focus on remaining on the fractal best described as a 'tape' - almost exclusively. I do, on occassion, intentionally "jump fractals" because doing so remains my first recourse (based on how I originally learned these methods). When I first learned to follow the Price / Volume Relationship, I used all tools available (Coarse, Medium and Fine). As a result, a "signal for change" represented a reason to reverse (irrespective of fractal chosen for trading). It isn't an 'easier' path by any means. It was simply the only path availble at the time (to me, based on my own mental filters).

 

Over the years, I've attempted to make life somewhat easier (some may argue that I haven't succeeded in that regard) by encouraging people to focus on one tool (Coarse) before moving onto another.

 

While I agree, actually trading these methods involves far more than simply drawing lines on a chart, profitable trading represents the consequence of a fully differentiated mind. In other words, unless one knows why someone has placed a specific line on a specific chart, at a specific point in time, then one might as well flip a coin. However, a complete and thoroughly annotated chart does indeed provide all the answers anyone ever needs.

 

HTH.

 

- Spydertrader

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Again, thanks for the reply.

Your answer is very interesting to me. I met a fellow in a trading room about a year ago, who seemed to be ahead of my curve, and that gentlemen was kind enough to lend some direction. First, he told me that the 5min chart was the chart to use, and he focused on price and volume. Up to that point, I had always believed volume held the key, and that any attempt to predict price in a vacuum from volume seemed irrational. So his comments resonated with me.

 

But little is written about volume, and of course most of what is written about trading is just wrong. But what really struck me about your thread, was your method of teaching, because this guy was exactly the same way. He would answer a question with a question, always making me seek the answer myself. His style is so similar to yours, that I wondered if perhaps both of you were mentored by the same individual.

 

You said you trade the "tape" almost exclusively. Do you always wait for a 5min candle to complete before acting, or will you close or open a position sometimes in anticipation of the candles outcome? I would think that as price reaches a target, one might want to exit even though a candle has not closed. Or do you ever drop down to a 1 or 3 minute chart?

 

Thanks for your time.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You said you trade the "tape" almost exclusively. Do you always wait for a 5min candle to complete before acting, or will you close or open a position sometimes in anticipation of the candles outcome?

 

While I often enter prior to the close of a five minute bar, doing so certainly isn't a requirement. "At some point" before the close of a 5 minute bar, the market 'locks into place' the next step in the order of events. While the "at some point" time develops at a different point in time (relative to the close) for every bar, one can learn to correctly anticipate 'what must come next' by using medium and / or fine level tools. However, on most days I trade, I am in no rush, and since I prefer to chat on the phone or sit outside, rather than, glue myself to a computer chair, I'm perfectly content to wait until the close of a bar before I take action.

 

I would think that as price reaches a target, one might want to exit even though a candle has not closed. Or do you ever drop down to a 1 or 3 minute chart?

 

I don't use 'candlestick' charts. I use OHLC 'Bar' Charts.

 

I don't set 'Price Targets' before entering a trade. I have no idea how long a particular trend will last, nor any clue as to how far Price will move when I enter. I only know how trends begin and how they end. Trends begin and end in the exact same fashion, it turns out. Of course, this answer also depends on 'context'. For example, if I see the market has reached 'Point Two' of a specific container at 3:50 PM Eastern Time, well, I'm going to exit, rather than hold between Points Two and Points Three.

 

With respect to 'dropping down' to faster time frames, unless I have the Medium Level Tools on my computer screen (two minute YM / STR - SQU), I have no need to use anything other than an ES 5 minute chart. Remember, this whole deal works (quite effectively) on a daily chart (and any other time frame for that matter). Effectiveness and Efficiency come into play once one has mastered the initial steps needed to see that which the market has provided.

 

HTH.

 

- Spydertrader

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That makes good sense. One of the demons I have been trying to rid myself of is exiting winning trades too soon. I know I am exiting based on reasons other then what is being provided by the chart. It is not that I don't know how to read the chart, I just need to better learn to control myself, which is all anyone can control once in a trade.

 

Do you have any reason why you prefer OHLC bars to candles? Doesn't seem to me an important difference, but you seem to feel that candles may obscure the message of the markets?

 

Thanks again

 

drwarbuck

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • there is not time line to success, some would take months, others years, at most its a constant continues process of struggle, I have been trading a hotforex account for 8 years now, and i dont think im close to what people call successful, but im happy with what little i make.  
    • forex trading is no joke, its  amoney hole for those who dont know what they are doing. its like a "now u see me now u dont" with money, it takes time to understand and study, it takes years to come up with a working strategy, and tons and tons of patience. some people are better off treating it as a hobbie or a past time really. though ive been in it for a decade now.
    • Ripple (XRP) Reaches $0.12 Oversold Region As Buyers Emerge Key Resistance Levels: $0.30, $0.40, $0.45 Key Support Levels: $0.25, $0.20, $0.15 XRP/USD Long-term Trend: Bearish Ripple is presently fluctuating between $0.12 and $0.17. The market appears to have reached bearish exhaustion as the coin reached the oversold region of the market. At a low of $0.12, XRP was oversold. Consequently, the bulls emerge to push XRP upward. The coin rises to a high of $0.15 and resumes consolidation. On the downside, as the price fell to a low of $0.12 and became oversold, a further downward move is doubtful. On the upside, if the bulls break the $0. 17 overhead resistances, XRP will resume an upward move. Meanwhile, the sideways trend may persist if the $0.17 resistance is unbroken. XRP/USD – Daily Chart Daily Chart Indicators Reading: Ripple is trading above 40% range of the daily stochastic. It indicates that Ripple is in bullish momentum but the current upward move is weak. This is in view of the currently prevailing bear market. The moving averages are pointing southward. XRP/USD Medium-term Trend: Ranging On the 4-hour chart, Ripple is in a sideways trend as the market fluctuates between $0.12 and $0.17. Ripple was earlier oversold as the market reached bearish exhaustion. Selling pressure is unlikely as the bulls emerge at the oversold. XRP/USD – 4 Hour Chart 4-hour Chart Indicators Reading Ripple is now in a horizontal channel as the price fluctuates between $0.12 and $0.17. Meanwhile, Ripple is rising as it reaches level 59 of the Relative Strength index. Ripple is above the centerline 50 indicating that it is in the Uptrend zone. Nevertheless, the 21-day and 50-day SMAs are sloping horizontally indicating the sideways trend. General Outlook for Ripple (XRP) Ripple is at the bottom of the chart but it is trading at $0.15 as at the time of writing. The pair is likely to continue its consolidation for a few more days. Presently, the bulls are having the upper hand as the price fluctuates upwards. It is assumed that the selling pressure has been exhausted. Ripple (XRP) Trade Signal Instrument: XRP/USD Order: Buy Entry price: $0.162 Stop: $0.150 Target: $0.362   Source: https://learn2.trade 
    • EURJPY Extends The Sell-Off From The Weekly Highs Towards The Sub-118.87 Region EURJPY Price Analysis – March 27 EURJPY fell under market pressure and tumbled to sub-118.87 levels at the time of writing. Japan’s anti-risk yen attained significant ground in the US session, driving the cross to session lows near 118.87 level amid the wide-spread vulnerability of the US dollar and the fall in US stock futures. Key Levels Resistance Levels: 123.37, 122.87, 121.15 Support Levels: 117.08, 115.83, 114.84 EURJPY Long term Trend: Bearish In the larger structure, the trend stays bearish as the cross returned still within the falling channel formed since 123.37 (high). As long as the resistance level is 122.87, the downward trend may proceed in the next session towards the support level of 114.84. Even so, a continuous break of 122.87 may achieve a double bottom level (115.83, 117.08) which may suggest a long-term bullish reversal. EURJPY Short term Trend: Ranging Initially, the EURJPY trend barely changed. Consolidation from a level of 115.83 can be increased through further rises. On the contrary, a break of 121.15 level will approach a resistance level of 122.87. On the downside, a continuous break of 115.83 level may suggest a greater resumption of the downward trend. The price is testing the 119.99 resistance level even though the cross may have a retest of the 120.17 and 121.15 price levels. Support is seen at levels of 119.24, 118.87 and 118.37. Instrument: EURJPY Order: Sell Entry price: 120.17 Stop: 120.67 Target: 119.24 Source: https://learn2.trade 
    • This is an absolute truth. You will not become a millionaire in a week. That doesn't happen in forex if you are a small fish like most of people here. Be patient and study as much as possible.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.