Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Eiger

[VSA] Volume Spread Analsysis Part III

Recommended Posts

Since the VSA II thread now has over 2,200 posts and 128,000 visits, it seemed time to start VSA III. To get us rolling, here is quick VSA look at how the market unfolded this morning on the 3-minute time frame (S&P e-minis).

 

 

The market opened higher than yesterday’s close, fell off over the first 15 minutes to A, and then tried to rally.

 

B – the rally to B did not bring out demand, and the bars at B were weak, closing on their lows.

 

C – A very weak bar with an increase in spread and volume to the downside. Supply came into the market here.

 

D – No demand on the first rally after weakness appeared and a good short.

 

E – Volume drops off as the market moves lower into the area of yesterday’s close.

 

F – A bottom reversal on good spread indicating demand.

 

G – the market tests the lows of E/F and is unable to draw supply. As it begins to rally, it tests again at G1.

 

H – An increase in volume with a good close, but the spread narrows – caution for longs.

 

J – Down bar, on wide spread and high volume shows supply has reentered the market.

 

J – No Demand followed by a small hidden upthrust.

 

K – Again we come back into the lows and find no supply and the market rallies.

 

T – Tests occur below the resistance at I indicating a rally and a break of I.

 

L – small bottom reversal/key reversal bar which tests for supply by dipping lower one last time before moving up to close on its high.

 

M – Break through the resistance at I and a rally into the noon hour. Note that the volume falls off as we move into the noon hour and come into the morning supply at A.

 

Hope this is helpful,

 

Eiger

5aa70ecd87231_ES3-minMay609.thumb.png.61752d084a144dfcd153f5e223eaec02.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

At the start of this new thread I'd like to share with you an indicator that someone made for me. The idea was as follows: VSA folks often place significance on volume that's less than the previous two bars. Why not create an indicator that reflects this by painting such a volume histogram blue? Well, I started with Tradestation's "Volume Average" indicator (standard issue) and tried to play around with it myself to adapt it, but I'm not good enough at EasyLanguage, so I threw it out to the Tradestation forum and somebody coded up for me the indicator I've got attached.

 

As you can see from the attached chart, it doesn't work so hot. All the vertical lines are places where the volume was less than the previous 2 bars, but it didn't get a blue color added to it. I'm not sure why that is. If someone can fix it so it correctly shows each and every instance where the volume of a given bar is less than the previous two, I'd be very grateful.

 

As it is, the indicator does have some value, especially when you get multiple bars with decreasing volume. It just gives you a visual cue that can be especially helpful when scanning charts.

 

Good trading all,

Tasuki

Volume Avg Vol2Less1.ELD

5aa70ece0defc_VolumeAvgVol2Less1.thumb.png.3e49563d38356bfe47c00fb35b4c5499.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
At the start of this new thread I'd like to share with you an indicator that someone made for me. The idea was as follows: VSA folks often place significance on volume that's less than the previous two bars. Why not create an indicator that reflects this by painting such a volume histogram blue? Well, I started with Tradestation's "Volume Average" indicator (standard issue) and tried to play around with it myself to adapt it, but I'm not good enough at EasyLanguage, so I threw it out to the Tradestation forum and somebody coded up for me the indicator I've got attached.

 

As you can see from the attached chart, it doesn't work so hot. All the vertical lines are places where the volume was less than the previous 2 bars, but it didn't get a blue color added to it. I'm not sure why that is. If someone can fix it so it correctly shows each and every instance where the volume of a given bar is less than the previous two, I'd be very grateful.

 

As it is, the indicator does have some value, especially when you get multiple bars with decreasing volume. It just gives you a visual cue that can be especially helpful when scanning charts.

 

Good trading all,

Tasuki

 

Thanks for posting this. It would be a very useful paintbar application. It is interesting that you post this now as I just sent a check out today to open an account at TradeStation. I haven't used TS for quite some time, but when I did, I thought it was quite good. So, I would find this helpful as well. It would also be useful to color code the price bars as up (higher close than previous bar's close), down (lower close than previous bar's close) and level (same close) -- see example in the chart in the first post on this thread. If no one picks up on this in a day or two, I'll copy it into the coding forum and make the request there. Thanks, Tas - it's a good idea.

 

Eiger

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like ask Eiger ,what do you think about it. ??

It is chart 5 min ES yesterday.

http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1241665291_84_UploadImage.png

After spring (S) bar 12,30 -- 12,35 h. I looked for test bar but I didnt find, so I didnt take long trade.

 

It is chart 5 min ES yesterday too,but every bar starts 9,37 -- 9,42,--- 9,47 h.......

http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1241665703_93_UploadImage.png

Here I see test (T) in bar 12,37-12,42h. What is your opininion. It is good take long trade after this test bar ???

Thank you

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Thanks for posting this. It would be a very useful paintbar application. It is interesting that you post this now as I just sent a check out today to open an account at TradeStation. I haven't used TS for quite some time, but when I did, I thought it was quite good. So, I would find this helpful as well. It would also be useful to color code the price bars as up (higher close than previous bar's close), down (lower close than previous bar's close) and level (same close) -- see example in the chart in the first post on this thread. If no one picks up on this in a day or two, I'll copy it into the coding forum and make the request there. Thanks, Tas - it's a good idea.

 

Eiger

 

Hi Eiger

 

I've been hesitant to post the volume indicator I am using because I am not a very efficient programmer and also don't really want to start supporting indicators, but here it goes... Maybe someone can use this as a building block, or optimize the code.

 

The colors used are:

Green = Regular up bar

Dark Green = No Demand

Red = Regular down bar

Dark Red = No Supply

White = Same close than previous bar on higher volume

Yellow = Same close than previous bar on lowest volume in two bars

Magenta = Highest Volume of last two bars, smallest range of last two bar and at a 5 bar high or low.

 

I also plot the 20 bar moving average of volume and 1.5 and 2 times the average volume.

 

I am using MultiCharts, but the code should compile on TradeStation.

 

inputs:	PlotAvg(True), 
	AvgLength(20 ), 
	Val1(1.5),
	Val2(2),
	UpColor(Green),
	DownColor(Red),
	NoDemandColor(DarkGreen),
	NoSupplyColor(DarkRed),
	ChurnColor(magenta);	

variables: 
Vol( 0 ),
VolAvg( 0 ),
StdVal(0),
Body(0);

If BarType >= 2 then Vol = Volume else Vol = Ticks;	

VolAvg = AverageFC(Vol, AvgLength ) ; 
StdVal = StandardDev(Vol, AvgLength, 1) ;

Plot1(Vol, "Vol" );
If PlotAvg then begin
Plot2(VolAvg, "VolAvg" ) ;
Plot3(VolAvg * Val1,"SDV1");
Plot4(VolAvg * Val2,"SDV2");
end;	


if C > C[1] then begin
SetPlotColor( 1, UpColor ); 
If Vol < Lowest(Vol,2)[1] then SetPlotColor(1,NoDemandColor);
end	
else if C < C[1] then begin
SetPlotColor( 1, DownColor ) ;
If Vol < Lowest(Vol,2)[1] then SetPlotColor(1,NoSupplyColor);	
end	
else begin
if C = C[1] then SetPlotColor(1,White);
If Vol < Lowest(Vol,2)[1] then SetPlotColor(1,Yellow);	
end;	

If (Vol > Vol[1] and Vol > Vol[2]) and Range <= Lowest(Range,2)[1] and 
(High = Highest(High,5) or Low = Lowest(low,5)) then SetPlotColor(1,ChurnColor);

5aa70ece15866_VSAVolume.thumb.png.877c3b3f110cb1fc3c75f8640b12fdb9.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi Eiger

 

I've been hesitant to post the volume indicator I am using because I am not a very efficient programmer and also don't really want to start supporting indicators, but here it goes... Maybe someone can use this as a building block, or optimize the code.

 

The colors used are:

Green = Regular up bar

Dark Green = No Demand

Red = Regular down bar

Dark Red = No Supply

White = Same close than previous bar on higher volume

Yellow = Same close than previous bar on lowest volume in two bars

Magenta = Highest Volume of last two bars, smallest range of last two bar and at a 5 bar high or low.

 

I also plot the 20 bar moving average of volume and 1.5 and 2 times the average volume ...

 

 

Hi Sevensa,

 

Thanks for posting this. I am glad you did -- it's a big help.

 

FWIW - For volume, I have always used a standard deviation function off the 20-period SMA of the volume. Even though our data is not normally distributed, the standard deviation function gives us a pretty good sense of the probabilities of the volume bar. We know, for example, that about 68 percent of all individual volume bars should fall within one SD of the mean. When the volume hits or exceeds 2 SDs,we know it can be significant (either producing an impulse move when pushing though a trading range or stopping/climactic volume). An upper Bollinger Band applied to the volume or a SD function both do the same job.

 

Hope this is helpful,

 

Eiger

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I would like ask Eiger ,what do you think about it. ??

It is chart 5 min ES yesterday.

http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1241665291_84_UploadImage.png

After spring (S) bar 12,30 -- 12,35 h. I looked for test bar but I didnt find, so I didnt take long trade.

 

It is chart 5 min ES yesterday too,but every bar starts 9,37 -- 9,42,--- 9,47 h.......

http://www.sierrachart.com/userimages/upload_2/1241665703_93_UploadImage.png

Here I see test (T) in bar 12,37-12,42h. What is your opininion. It is good take long trade after this test bar ???

Thank you

 

Springs are one of my favoirte trades. I have studied and traded them for a long time and have a pretty good grasp on their characteristics. Because of that, I usually don't wait for a test for confirmation. Many times springs will just take off like it did here.

 

So, how would you know whether a spring has high odds or not. Your chart has all the characteristics I look for in a spring:

 

First, the background. Here, the market is in an uptrend. It has made higher highs and higher lows. Springs do not work well in a downtrend. I never take a spring when the trend is down unless a clear SOS and a base (cause) have occured. When I see an uptrend in place, I start thinking pullbacks and springs. Note that once again, the all-important background is always the first consideration.

 

What is particularly nice about this spring is that there was a reaction back to support on relatively light volume. This is a choice setup; I really like this look. It is described in the Wyckoff texts as a Jump Across the Creek, and then a Back Up to the the Edge of the Creek. The creek represents supply and the jump across the creek indicates a sign of strength. The market will frequently come back to the edge of the creek and test, as it did here. Testing in this context means not on a single bar as in VSA, but coming back into the area of supply (red curved line) aand testing it to make sure no additional supply is there which would thwart an up move. Volume on the reaction was lighter than the rally.

 

The bar before the Sping was telling. That bar looked ominous, closing on its low and closing lower than the closes of the last four bars. Volume did not increase substantially, however, and the spring bar dipped lower, turned around, closed on its highs, and volume came in. If you were watching this bar develop real time, you would have seen the volume come in as the bar rallied up - this is demand off the bottom. The spring bar is also a bottom reversal in VSA terms, so it had that going for it, too.

 

The final piece to this is that the spring bar was powerful enough to come right up to the minor supply line of the reaction. Any further advance in price would take out this line, which occured shortly thereafter.

 

Regarding switching how the chart displays the bars to look for confirmation -- I personally wouldn't do that. This is akin to committing "confirmation bias," or looking for indications you normally don't look at to support a decision. It is better to either study springs until you are completely confident in trading them without a test for confirmation or specifying that a spring must be confirmed by a test and if a test does not occur, just let the trade pass. Either is perfectly fine.

 

If your criteria includes a test and a test does not occur, so what. A trade was missed. No big deal. There is always another good trade coming just around the next corner. If you note on the chart after rallying aggressively off the spring, the market moved up above the last high (HH) making another new high, rested, held its gains, and gave a nice VSA Test for entry (green arrow).

 

Hope this is helpful,

 

Eiger

5aa70ece3834d_SpringMay509.png.0dbd2c11e9f6ee7623da0ccd720be0e7.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am using MultiCharts, but the code should compile on TradeStation.

 

 

Yes, it does work in Tradestation version 8.6 build 2525.

Very nice indicator. thanks, sevensa.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I just wanna say thank you for opening this new thread!I hope that it will be as successful as other 2 : }

 

I second that..

Anyone trade forex here? I just found this forum and haven't finished reading VSA I or VSA II..

 

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You will discover the answer to that as you read through the threads! Don't be fooled by what people tell you, there is no volume reported on forex, People happily (and successfully apparently) use tick volume as a proxy for volume. Be aware it is only actually a proxy for order book activity so you get ticks without trades taking place. For example If I best bid then cancel it this will cause ticks without a trade taking place. So in short why pick an instrument where there is no volume reported when there hundreds of thousands where there is?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You will discover the answer to that as you read through the threads! Don't be fooled by what people tell you, there is no volume reported on forex, People happily (and successfully apparently) use tick volume as a proxy for volume. Be aware it is only actually a proxy for order book activity so you get ticks without trades taking place. For example If I best bid then cancel it this will cause ticks without a trade taking place. So in short why pick an instrument where there is no volume reported when there hundreds of thousands where there is?

 

Did you mean to trade others than forex?

I saw people trade successfully in forex with VSA at another forum..but the forum didn't have much info coz they were focusing on indicators..

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Did you mean to trade others than forex?

I saw people trade successfully in forex with VSA at another forum..but the forum didn't have much info coz they were focusing on indicators..

 

If you are keen on trading currency why not trade Currency futures (CME) a regulated market and where true vol is reported, VSA principles will work just as well and the moves will be in line with forex, only less spikey.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If you are keen on trading currency why not trade Currency futures (CME) a regulated market and where true vol is reported, VSA principles will work just as well and the moves will be in line with forex, only less spikey.

 

Absolutely. Not only that they have recently introduced mini futures (which I hear are picking up in liquidity) which would suit those with smaller accounts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
.... Be aware it is only actually a proxy for order book activity so you get ticks without trades taking place. For example If I best bid then cancel it this will cause ticks without a trade taking place...

 

I have always understood tick volume (in general) to reflect actual trades and not withdrawn bids/offers, but then I don't trade FX, so this is new for me?? When I traded commodities futures years ago I do remember seeing a study done comparing tick with true volume in commodities (grains, I think) and having a correlation of about 85-90%.

 

In addition to currency futures and emini futures, there are currency ETFs with good liquidity and, thus, good volume.

 

Eiger

Edited by Eiger

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eiger

 

Do you have any VSA related indicator/template for ensign, that I can use. Some posted alerts, but I am able to put up those alers in ensign. The alerts painted bars with volume < 2 previous bars and r quite helpful. Any1 could upload them as a template here.

Thanks

 

Thanks for posting this. It would be a very useful paintbar application. It is interesting that you post this now as I just sent a check out today to open an account at TradeStation. I haven't used TS for quite some time, but when I did, I thought it was quite good. So, I would find this helpful as well. It would also be useful to color code the price bars as up (higher close than previous bar's close), down (lower close than previous bar's close) and level (same close) -- see example in the chart in the first post on this thread. If no one picks up on this in a day or two, I'll copy it into the coding forum and make the request there. Thanks, Tas - it's a good idea.

 

Eiger

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Eiger

 

As the thread starter, maybe u may want to come up with some directives for newbies who accidentally came across this thread and start posing noobie questions without reading part 1 and part 2. I think it should be mandatory reading for any VSA enthusiasts to read Tom Williams MTM, and to at least take the time to read the 1st 10 pages of part 1 and part 2, before posing questions. Another second directive should be that when noobies or recent arrivals to VSA posed questions, their questions should be annoted on charts. Certain directives need to be put to grow the thread, so that we can each day come and poss our readings, or better, post mo realtime developments on the charts.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Eiger

 

As the thread starter, maybe u may want to come up with some directives for newbies who accidentally came across this thread and start posing noobie questions without reading part 1 and part 2. I think it should be mandatory reading for any VSA enthusiasts to read Tom Williams MTM, and to at least take the time to read the 1st 10 pages of part 1 and part 2, before posing questions. Another second directive should be that when noobies or recent arrivals to VSA posed questions, their questions should be annoted on charts. Certain directives need to be put to grow the thread, so that we can each day come and poss our readings, or better, post mo realtime developments on the charts.

 

See this thread:

 

http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/f151/helpful-ideas-for-newcomers-to-vsa-5944.html#post64769

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is what i try hard to learn.The backgroung.I read a lot of post from a lot of tarders and saw that most common mistake is not to look for the background.Pro traders or expirienced one talk much abt it but no one say this and this is the background.So that`s why i post this to see if anyone could give me a reasonable explanation if this is a valid signal not based only on these individual bars but on the back ground.As for background looking in my charts i see no previous highs or something i see that the trend is down.This is short term down from yesterday.This is the only thing i can see.So could someone give me reasonable explanation why this should be a good short or why not due to all we need to enter a tarde .. background and individual bars ... Thanks a lot.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • This is simply one part you have defined here. lack of knowledge and awareness is also another part than needs to be consider before starting trading. 
    • The theme over this last trading week has been one of remarkable resilience. After breaking down from key resistance levels, it seemed that a period of consolidation would follow. But, globally, markets instead rallied with conviction to retest their highs. I have been sceptical about the sustainability of the rally this year. But one of the most fundamental axioms of surviving the markets is to trade what you see, not what you believe. And what I am seeing is markets that seem to want to push higher across the board, with individual stocks holding up well even when faced with bearish news. S&P 500 (credit: chart from Sigma by Hydra X) The S&P closed the week strongly at 2,822.48, up 0.5% on high volume, and on the back of its biggest weekly gain since November 2018. US markets seem insistent on forging a path higher despite the overhang of earnings, macro economy news, North Korea, and ongoing China trade talks. I still wait for price to break and close clear of the congestion zone around 2,800 before entering longs, but this looks increasingly like a environment where the only rational positions to take are either to be flat or long. MICROSOFT (credit: chart from Sigma by Hydra X) Gains this week were led by tech, with the sector surging 4.9%, and also becoming the best performing sector of 2019. I find MSFT interesting, having completed a bullish inverse head and shoulders pattern, rallying in a tight rising channel, and strongly testing resistance (and also its all-time highs) on high volume. But a spinning top candlestick in the midst of overhead resistance, and a bearish stochastic crossover which in overbought territory could translate into a pullback, which could provide interesting entries for longs. TESLA (credit: chart from Sigma by Hydra X) A good litmus test for market sentiment is how stocks behave on news. Tesla has held on to $275 support despite its Model Y unveiling event underwhelming analysts; BAML, CFRA Research and Canaccord Genuity all issued cautionary notes. If it gets there, $260 looks to be strong support for a countertrend rally. BOEING (credit: chart from Sigma by Hydra X) Boeing continued to suffer the aftermath of the latest tragedy, ultimately having to suspend its entire fleet of 737 MAX planes when the FAA finally followed the lead of global aviation authorities in grounding the plane. Deliveries of the 737 MAX have also been paused. The beleaguered company faces an indeterminate outcome from investigations, bills from airlines affected by the grounding of the plane, as well as potential suits from the families of victims. On Thursday, the US Air Force joined the party. It launched a blistering attack on Boeing, saying that the company has a ‘severe situation’ after flawed inspections of their KC-46 air refuelling tanker aircraft, and questioning the company’s ‘culture of discipline for safety’. [https://www.cnn.com/2019/03/14/politics/air-force-boeing-refueling-plane/index.html] Despite all this, the stock has proven remarkably well supported at $370, repeatedly rallying from those levels on high volume. FACEBOOK (credit: chart from Sigma by Hydra X) No company has had a worse week than FB, even within the context of its bad year. The week started with a proposal by Senator Elizabeth Warren to break up FB, was followed by a network outage affecting its Facebook, WhatsApp and Instagram services, and then announcements of a widening federal criminal probe into its data sharing practices. Two key executives, Chris Cox and Chris Daniels also announced their departures from the company. A nadir was reached when its Facebook application was used to livestream the hate-driven massacre of 49 people in New Zealand. Technically, the stock has broken below the bottom of its ascending channel, and key overhead resistance in the $170-173 region looks daunting. There is also a huge gap from Feb 2019 waiting to be closed. Yet in spite of the weak technical picture and the deluge of negative news, FB closed just 2.13% down for the week, and ended the trading session on Friday well above the lows of the day, forming a bullish hammer. While I have been waiting for a clear break in one direction or the other for a while, as rising channel met overhead resistance, I choose to stay as interested spectators for now. EUR/USD (credit: chart from Sigma by Hydra X) Finally, last week I noted the technical breakdown of key support levels in the EURUSD, in conjunction with fundamentally bearish news in the form of Draghi’s dovish speech. However, I was keen to stay on the sidelines, given past experience of how crowded trades tend to turn out. EURUSD didn’t disappoint, as it promptly rose in a stop-hunting rally, which would have trapped any short entries in a very uncomfortable position.
    • Learn the concepts of options first and do demo trading, that is the only tips that anybody can give you. Your knowledge ans skills are going to help you for options trading.
    • It was good article for options knowledge but the fact is that many traders actually see it like it is gambling and somehow it also works like gambling. So working with options in real money is more risky.
    • $EVER (EVER) EverQuote stock bull flag breakout watch above 8.04, large upside price gap,analysis https://stockconsultant.com/?EVER
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.