[noego]

This is simply another attack Kiwi....most people are NOT in the room to have their trades called for them. Most are there because he willingly teaches all day long and answers emails late into the night to truly assist other traders in becoming better. He preaches everyday to learn this stuff so that you can do it on your own in a market of YOUR choosing. Speaking without knowing for yourself is no different than those who defend. Take the time to observe for a month or two and see if the honesty about the market and the perils it provides those who do not take the time to learn before trading are not preached on a constant basis. I know Huddy would agree with me that there are some absolutely fantastic technicians out there. He readily admits to being good but not great or perfect. And he begs the members of his room to be selective and safe every single day. There are no "get rich" quick promises ever. Only the willingness to help others. I am disgusted by this entire thread.

[MightyMouse]

Originally Posted by Kiwi »

Another guru; another defensive attack.

Whenever you get a stack of one post wonders I suspect that its like old Covell stacking the Amazon reviews in his favour so people would waste their money on his book.

The gang is here. And one day, if they survive their infatuation with someone calling their trades for them they just might become traders. For now they are just another type of spammer.

Kiwi,


I am usually pretty skeptical about things I read about trading, but seeing all these positive responses to the channel trading room made me curious so i signed up and, its hard to believe, but since this morning I have lost 5 pounds of weight and no longer have the urge to smoke cigarettes. Thanks Hud!

You may want to open up your mind too.



MM

[ricochet]

Swisstrader1,

I have been in Kevin's room for just under a year. I converse with him all throughout each trading day. I know him to be the most helpful, honest, consistent and disciplined trader and person I have ever met. The way he teaches and runs his room is more professional than you will find anywhere. As with most traders we occasionally search around to find out what's new or for a better way to use something we like, in my case MP. Huddy's sense of the market and his amazing way of using MP in concert with Price Action is better than anything I have ever tried in my previous 7 years of trading. His accuracy with entries, targets and stops is simply just incredible. He does call all his trades prior to entry and manages them in the most efficient way possible. Being in his room, listening to his advise, watching him trade and manage the trade, has improved my trading more in the last year than I've done myself and in other rooms, in the last 6 years. Kevin does much more than just call trades; he does what ever it takes to help his traders. If I were just starting out in trading this is the one and only room I would want to be in. As far as I'm concerned his integrity is beyond reproach. I am glad to call him my friend and hope to trade along side him for the rest of my trading career.

Kiwi,

Obviously you skimmed the post for Kevin and didn't get the meaning in them, too bad. Maybe you should go back and reread them, see what it means to be a part of something that is good and helpful. Not slam the posters for supporting what they believe in.

For any bystanders that don't know of Kevin and Channel-Trading.com, don't let a couple disgruntled posters influence you, come in the room and make your own informed judgment.

[slow]

Originally Posted by swisstrader1 »

I will not get into a lengthy discussion here about whoever´s credibility. I think sooner or later we all came across "educators" that seem to be good traders while they are truly o(at best) maybe good analysts.
To make a long story very short. I (part)own a small swiss asset management firm and kevin hudson (huddy) from channel-trading traded for us for a short period of time and i can tell for FACT based on the live trades he took, that he did nothing but lose and that VERY consistently! It was not so much the fact that he lost 50k in a heartbeat but the way he lost it.
If you think Im making this up, I could send some moderater our agreement with huddy as well as the live trading statement and some email reference with him.
I also know a couple of traders that have been in his room for a few months and all of them had the same issues. Huddy makes very often calls like "I will be looking to sell in that area..." and when price gets there you hear nothing from him (let alone you will never see his DOM). If the market acts as "called" he of course took the trade and "you should already have a scale off now" and if the market blows through the level he is "glad I didnt stand in front of that!" Its this would have, could have, should have stuff and I dont know about you, but "would have, could have, should have" does not make you any money in this business!

swisstrader1

As a new member I find your post interesting:

1) 50k is really not that big of loss in a managed futures fund

2) a little due diligence on your part could have easily prevented this

3) I find it hard to believe that you were forced to let the trading continue

4) it has been my experience that the futures markets are no place for whiners

regards,
slow

[mabeek]

Swiss Trader; You do lend humor to this thread, but people are looking for objective information.

[Kiwi]

LOL. Love the last three posts.

One can only hope that some of these folk hang around beyond the "defend my guru" phase and contribute something useful to the board.

[noego]

Time for this thread to die. There will be no winners here. This is clearly not a forum where fair and honest critiques are given. Allowing this to continue on the part of the staff here has taken a fair and honest dialogue and watch it become Jerry Springer TV. No value for anyone at this point. I support the right of people to give a fair critique of any business. Slander and open use of the internet for self serving purposes should be snuffed out.

[MadMarketScientist]

This is a forum, and it is a place people can go to express their opinions. Clearly you've made your point that you disagree and there's been a very open dialogue between everyone/anyone who has wanted to weigh in. This is the internet and if you've spent any time on it, it is clearly a place where people are free to express themselves. You don't have to like the critiques/opinions, and people are free to refute them but as long as it stays on topic, it's a fair discussion. Personally I cannot see what is self serving about it - and if you've spent any time in forums, in particular trading forums it certainly is common to have very critical opinions of virtually any service, strategy, broker, etc... and there are just as many supporters. That's the way it goes. People are free to speak their mind - including on TL.

MMS

Originally Posted by noego »

Time for this thread to die. There will be no winners here. This is clearly not a forum where fair and honest critiques are given. Allowing this to continue on the part of the staff here has taken a fair and honest dialogue and watch it become Jerry Springer TV. No value for anyone at this point. I support the right of people to give a fair critique of any business. Slander and open use of the internet for self serving purposes should be snuffed out.