Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

optiontimer

Trend & Momentum - Indicators of Choice II

Which indicator should I use to determine long-term trend for my trading system?  

106 members have voted

  1. 1. Which indicator should I use to determine long-term trend for my trading system?

    • Single Moving Average
      23
    • Dual Moving Averages (Short MA relative to Long MA)
      46
    • MACD
      13
    • Bollinger Bands
      10
    • Donchian Channel
      5
    • Other (Please post your suggestion to the thread when choosing this option)
      9


Recommended Posts

This poll is related to this previous poll posted last week here at Traderslaboratory:

 

Lately, I see many posts/threads here at Traderslaboratory about traders who are struggling, wondering if they should give up and quit, wondering why they can't "get it."

 

I would like to try to help.

 

I am going to put together an indicator trading system and trading plan in real time here at Traderslaboratory.com

 

I want input from fellow posters/lurkers as to which indicators I should use.

 

I need one indicator to major trend, and one indicator to determine minor trend, which I consider most visible using a momentum oscillator.

 

I am going to try to post a poll. Please vote for your preferred indicator. In this poll, we will determine which momentum oscillator I will use to build the system. If you vote "other," please post in the thread which "other" you are suggesting.

 

As for the major trend indicator, that will be another poll. But if anyone would wish to make a suggestion for an indicator to include in that poll, please post your suggestions here.

 

Thank you for your participation.

 

-OT

 

The Traderslaboratory community selected the RSI as the indicator that I will use it to determine the short term trend for the trading system that we will put together here at Traderslaboratory.com. While the community selected the indicator, I will choose the period for the indicator as it will be applied to the system at hand.

 

Again, if you vote "other," be so kind as to post to this thread just what "other" indicator you would select.

 

Thank you for your participation,

 

-OT

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

suggestion -

donchian channel - but the mid point is used for determining the trend.

Below - generally downtrend, above uptrend

either use weekly (eg: 20 week) on the daily - or use 100 day (5days*20weeks)

They will give slightly different levels on many systems

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
suggestion -

donchian channel - but the mid point is used for determining the trend.

Below - generally downtrend, above uptrend

either use weekly (eg: 20 week) on the daily - or use 100 day (5days*20weeks)

They will give slightly different levels on many systems

 

Thank you, SIUYA, would you mind posting a chart as a visual aid to your explanation?

 

Thank you,

 

-OT

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I assume you're talking about long term trend on a daily, weekly, or monthly chart. I'm not being facetious, but if a trader can't see the current trend on one of those charts without an indicator, I would suggest that either there isn't a clear current trend to trade, or the trader may benefit more from some fundamental advice on what a trend is, than from an indicator which, being further removed from price action, he is less likely to understand?

 

Max

Edited by maxr

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I assume you're talking about long term trend on a daily, weekly, or monthly chart. I'm not being facetious, but if a trader can't see the current trend on one of those charts without an indicator, I would suggest that either there isn't a clear current trend to trade, or the trader may benefit more from some fundamental advice on what a trend is, than from an indicator which, being further removed from price action, he is less likely to understand?

 

Max

 

Hi Maxr

 

Normally what you are saying would be a valid, and nobody would argue with that.

But it may be off the mark here today.

And that may be because you have missed the point of this thread, and its predecessor here:

 

http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/f34/trend-momentum-indicators-choice-9893.html

 

Hopefully after reading the first thread you will understand what Optiontimer is constructing as a project.

 

He is doing this freely, and is simply asking members for their choice of long term and short term indicators, via a poll,

from which he will build a strategy shortly, and from there a trading plan.

 

Your statement is understandable, in the absence of the full context.

 

You seem to have a bit of knowledge and interest, so you are welcome to work within the intent of the project I am sure.

I am thrilled to have the opportunity to participate here, because I am not a profitable trader over a longer term.

My trading is like a Leopard - it looks good in spots!

 

By the way - Optiontimer was able to grow an a/c by nearly 50% under competition conditions during the month of May:

 

http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/24/traders-laboratory-forex-trading-contest-9303-3.html

 

See post #87. I look forward to what he has to say, much as a student would.

 

Also, if you go here:

 

https://fx2.oanda.com/mod_perl/fxcontest/fxcontest.pl?rm=contestDetails&contestId=1855

 

and select "Membership" it is easy to see Optiontimer had 29.1% profit for the first 2 trading days in June, before the comp folded.

I only mention this to establish that Optiontimer knows what he is doing, and has the credentials to accomplish something here,

if we are patient and give him room to develop his threads.

 

I am sure you are already aware of much of that, but I think it needed to be said to prevent further off-topic discussion.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
suggestion -

donchian channel - but the mid point is used for determining the trend.

Below - generally downtrend, above uptrend

either use weekly (eg: 20 week) on the daily - or use 100 day (5days*20weeks)

They will give slightly different levels on many systems

 

I am with you on the Donchian Channel, Siuya.

 

It is a little-understood indicator, developed by a man who is widely regarded as

the "father of trend following", Richard Donchian:

 

Richard Donchian - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

example attached.

http://www.traderslaboratory.com/forums/attachment.php?attachmentid=24881&stc=1&d=1307838912

 

It shows two sets of lines - one dark blue the other light blue.

The dark blue is a 20 bar Donchian channel based on weekly charts

The light blue is a 100 bar (5 days x 20 weeks) channel based on daily charts

 

Due to the nature of the program (in this case Esignal) the weekly seems more immediately reactive to moves and adjusts (or so it seems to Mondays, rather than waiting until the move may occur), hence from a historical point of view seems early, but when using it live it will be different.

Personally I dont think it matters which you use, so long as its consistent, and you understand why you are using it. Pick one or the other.

 

the reason for using the mid point is simple it gives a very clear indication to avoid certain bottom picking/top picking trades. It is an indicator as a filter only for me....and i dont use it to exit or enter (you will have similar issues as with a Moving avg) but unlike a MA it gives definite horizontal levels in the price.

 

(as per maxr - yes you are right - squint your eyes look at the chart and you can clearly see a trend - thats why these are indicators and can be used to filter out trades, keep traders on a checklist and help stop them punting wildly - it gives them the definition of a trend - plus a computer often needs something like a mathematical filter to be able to squint its eyes and see the same thing :))

snapshot-1.thumb.png.fe93eab41becb45b2fdb067eeb123850.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
...By the way - Optiontimer was able to grow an a/c by nearly 50% under competition conditions during the month of May...Also, if you go here...and select "Membership" it is easy to see Optiontimer had 29.1% profit for the first 2 trading days in June, before the comp folded. I only mention this to establish that Optiontimer knows what he is doing, and has the credentials to accomplish something here, if we are patient and give him room to develop his threads...

 

Thank you for the kind words, Ingot54.

 

I would like to point out two things:

 

1) My plan is eventually to develop a system which I will trade in a real money account as this project progresses, and

 

2) the results from trading a highly levered demo account in a contest will differ greatly in magnitude from what I would achieve trading a real money account.

 

My main goal will not be to gain x% per day or week or month. Rather, my main goal will be simple: No Losing Months. Losing trades? Of course. Net/net at the end of each month, the goal is to be flat to positive.

 

So let's get ready to not lose some money! (sometimes you need to split an infinitve to get you meaning across).

 

Thank You,

 

-OT

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What do you plan on using the system to trade - forex, stocks, options?

 

 

I'm glad you decided to join us, Carpet Cleaner.

 

What do I plan on trading? I might need yet another poll, hmmm?

 

For now, I'm open to suggestions from anyone who wishes to voice a preference as a sort of informal poll. I'll reserve the right to make the final decision as to what I'll be trading. I can say that I plan on setting up a sub-account at Interactivebrokers to trade the system, so I will have no limit as to which instrument(s) I trade except that of margin requirements and whatever money management regimen I implement. I'll transfer 25K into the sub-account it to prevent a PDT problem from arising should I choose to trade stocks or stock options.

 

As far as what to trade using the system we'll develop here, I'm open to suggestions. I may add a poll addressing the issue if for no other reason than to see where the preferences of Traderslaboratory.com users is concentrated.

 

Thank You,

 

-OT

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

optiontimer said:

 

....For now, I'm open to suggestions from anyone who wishes to voice a preference as a sort of informal poll. I'll reserve the right to make the final decision as to what I'll be trading....

 

Can I suggest Forex, optionstimer? When I was looking to find a good FX broker a while back, I found many unhappy bunnies in that area, and they weren't all on forexpeacearmy :-). Their woes extend from unscupulous brokers manipulating accounts, to the many expensive 'get rick quick' Forex systems that don't.

 

Anyyone, almost anywhere, can open a demo FX account for nothing, and a simple system which loses little or no money overall would really brighten up these traders' lives. I guess Forex would preclude using volume based indicators, but personally, as a long term student verging on trading seriously for real, I'd be very interested to see a good simple system largely based on price or analysis thereof. I think we'd also all benefit from your advice in passing on how to, err, avoid choosing the wrong broker when trading FX - that seems to be much more of an issue than with other instruments.

 

Max

Edited by maxr

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

 

Can I suggest Forex, optiontimer? When I was looking to find a good FX broker a while back, I found many unhappy bunnies in that area, and they weren't all on forexpeacearmy :-). Their woes extend from unscrupulous brokers manipulating accounts, to the many expensive 'get rick quick' Forex systems that don't.

 

Anyone, almost anywhere, can open a demo FX account for nothing, and a simple system which loses little or no money overall would really brighten up these traders' lives.

 

Max

I agree 100% with you Max. My reasons are selfish - I trade retail Forex.

 

But happy to go with the flow. I know that futures traders are also heavily represented on TL.

 

Ivan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I'll take all suggestions under advisement, but again, I reserve the final decison for myself.

 

I'd still like to hear from more traderslaboratory.com members about what they would prefer to see traded.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'll take all suggestions under advisement, but again, I reserve the final decison for myself.

 

I'd still like to hear from more traderslaboratory.com members about what they would prefer to see traded.

 

ES, thanks for asking.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

if its reasonably automated and not too high frequency how about a range of products.

eg; CL, EURUSD, USDJPY, AUDUSD, ES...... some of the currencies will get a bit correlated maybe.

 

If going for just one instrument my vote is EURUSD

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
I'll take all suggestions under advisement, but again, I reserve the final decison for myself.

 

I'd still like to hear from more traderslaboratory.com members about what they would prefer to see traded.

 

I'd have to vote ES for selfish reasons. I've been away for over a year and trying to get back into trading. The indicators that I was migrating to don't work under NT v7. So, I'm starting over but I don't want to try Forex yet.

 

There seems to be a lot of Forex interest now days, so I'll be watching no matter what.

 

Thanks for the thread OT!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Be careful who you blame.   I can tell you one thing for sure.   Effective traders don’t blame others when things start to go wrong.   You can hang onto your tendency to play the victim, or the martyr… but if you want to achieve in trading, you have to be prepared to take responsibility.   People assign reasons to outcomes, whether based on internal or external factors.   When traders face losses, it's common for them to blame bad luck, poor advice, or other external factors, rather than reflecting on their own personal attributes like arrogance, fear, or greed.   This is a challenging lesson to grasp in your trading journey, but one that holds immense value.   This is called attribution theory. Taking responsibility for your actions is the key to improving your trading skills. Pause and ask yourself - What role did I play in my financial decisions?   After all, you were the one who listened to that source, and decided to act on that trade based on the rumour. Attributing results solely to external circumstances is what is known as having an ‘external locus of control’.   It's a concept coined by psychologist Julian Rotter in 1954. A trader with an external locus of control might say, "I made a profit because the markets are currently favourable."   Instead, strive to develop an "internal locus of control" and take ownership of your actions.   Assume that all trading results are within your realm of responsibility and actively seek ways to improve your own behaviour.   This is the fastest route to enhancing your trading abilities. A trader with an internal locus of control might proudly state, "My equity curve is rising because I am a disciplined trader who faithfully follows my trading plan." Author: Louise Bedford Source: https://www.tradinggame.com.au/
    • SELF IMPROVEMENT.   The whole self-help industry began when Dale Carnegie published How to Win Friends and Influence People in 1936. Then came other classics like Think And Grow Rich by Napoleon Hill, Awaken the Giant Within by Tony Robbins toward the end of the century.   Today, teaching people how to improve themselves is a business. A pure ruthless business where some people sell utter bullshit.   There are broke Instagrammers and YouTubers with literally no solid background teaching men how to be attractive to women, how to begin a start-up, how to become successful — most of these guys speaking nothing more than hollow motivational words and cliche stuff. They waste your time. Some of these people who present themselves as hugely successful also give talks and write books.   There are so many books on financial advice, self-improvement, love, etc and some people actually try to read them. They are a waste of time, mostly.   When you start reading a dozen books on finance you realize that they all say the same stuff.   You are not going to live forever in the learning phase. Don't procrastinate by reading bull-shit or the same good knowledge in 10 books. What we ought to do is choose wisely.   Yes. A good book can change your life, given you do what it asks you to do.   All the books I have named up to now are worthy of reading. Tim Ferriss, Simon Sinek, Robert Greene — these guys are worthy of reading. These guys teach what others don't. Their books are unique and actually, come from relevant and successful people.   When Richard Branson writes a book about entrepreneurship, go read it. Every line in that book is said by one of the greatest entrepreneurs of our time.   When a Chinese millionaire( he claims to be) Youtuber who releases a video titled “Why reading books keeps you broke” and a year later another one “My recommendation of books for grand success” you should be wise to tell him to jump from Victoria Falls.   These self-improvement gurus sell you delusions.   They say they have those little tricks that only they know that if you use, everything in your life will be perfect. Those little tricks. We are just “making of a to-do-list before sleeping” away from becoming the next Bill Gates.   There are no little tricks.   There is no success-mantra.   Self-improvement is a trap for 99% of the people. You can't do that unless you are very, very strong.   If you are looking for easy ways, you will only keep wasting your time forgetting that your time on this planet is limited, as alive humans that is.   Also, I feel that people who claim to read like a book a day or promote it are idiots. You retain nothing. When you do read a good book, you read slow, sometimes a whole paragraph, again and again, dwelling on it, trying to internalize its knowledge. You try to understand. You think. It takes time.   It's better to read a good book 10 times than 1000 stupid ones.   So be choosy. Read from the guys who actually know something, not some wannabe ‘influencers’.   Edit: Think And Grow Rich was written as a result of a project assigned to Napoleon Hill by Andrew Carnegie(the 2nd richest man in recent history). He was asked to study the most successful people on the planet and document which characteristics made them great. He did extensive work in studying hundreds of the most successful people of that time. The result was that little book.   Nowadays some people just study Instagram algorithms and think of themselves as a Dale Carnegie or Anthony Robbins. By Nupur Nishant, Quora Profits from free accurate cryptos signals: https://www.predictmag.com/    
    • there is no avoiding loses to be honest, its just how the market is. you win some and hopefully more, but u do lose some. 
    • $CSCO Cisco Systems stock, nice top of range breakout, from Stocks to Watch at https://stockconsultant.com/?CSCOSEPN Septerna stock watch for a bottom breakout, good upside price gap
    • $CSCO Cisco Systems stock, nice top of range breakout, from Stocks to Watch at https://stockconsultant.com/?CSCOSEPN Septerna stock watch for a bottom breakout, good upside price gap
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.