Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.
Dr Who
-
Content Count
60 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Posts posted by Dr Who
-
-
It depends on what instruments you're talking about. In forex, there is no volume data at all so my only analysis is through price action, fibonacci levels, and session highs/lows, and natual S/R levels. In this case, all players are without this data so it's fair to everyone. In eminis, volume is an added and necessary data so using it is a must since you'll be at a disadvantage when others have access to it to give them an edge. Hope this helps.Torero,
For my case it is Forex. Though I was interested to know if there would be a common technique for all markets.
Ant,
Thanks for the good reply.
-
In my opinion it would not be wise to excluse volume from your analysis. Volume is the only tool that is not a derivative of price. Therefore the information is pure.Although I do not necessarily plot volume on my intraday charts, I can read volume through the tape. Perhaps you may want to look into divergence signals using delta like Tingull does. You can also trade price patterns, learn market internals to judge strength and weakness, etc... There are so many ways you can base your trading on. Good luck.
Thanks for the reply Soultrader.
-
I am interested in the most effective anlysis styles not using volume. My understanding is not all are in belief that volume moves price.
So without volume and just using price what are some amalysis methods that may provide what volume could help provide?
-
So this needs a very high win rate with very small losses.
-
Hi guys,
It is very slow and I use broadband too.
-
Sorry for the newbie question but are TD lines trendlines? ThanksThey are a type of trend line but objective due to their application.
You can read bout them here: TD Line Qualifiers and potential filters @ Forex Factory
-
How about using trendlines and moving averages?Try using TD lines!
They are used in Forex and can be used in other trading. They are OBJECTIVE trend lines with qualifiers to validate their signals - filtered trend lines. A trader can determine if a breakout is worth fading and if buying has been exhausted etc.
-
Ive read alot on this forum about indicators being useless. However, I do think price and indicator divergence signals can be taken as a powerful trading signal.If divergences such as RSI and MACD offers trading opportunities, why dont you guys use them? Thanks
Simply looking at divergences doesn't tell you WHY? Employing other methods at least gives you more insight. MACD tells you what price tells you as does RSI. Looking at divergences is like looking at a newspaper without taking it all in - sense my analogy? The talk is there, but what is in the talk? Tape reading helps.
No volume analysis
in Technical Analysis
Posted
TinGull,
I hadn't thought of tick volume.
Interesting your divergence strategy.
Thanks all.