Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

mitsubishi

Beyond Taylor

Recommended Posts

"Successful speculation is not based on any one set of inflexible rules and a trader must be ready to change when conditions change.However,the trader who knows how to act when the expected happens is in a better position to act when the unexpected happens"

 

From the preface of The Taylor Trading Technique by George Douglass Taylor

 

SPX March 5th-9th

 

Weekly range- 34.7 points

 

Mon range- 10.4 points

Tues range- 23.6 points

Weds range- 11.5 points

Thurs range- 16.1 points

Fri range- 8.8 points

 

Total- 70.4 points

 

If you measure every swing up/down throughout the week the total,of course increases.

How many points did you take last week?

 

Taylor devised some very good strategies for both intraday and swing trading that allow the trader to attempt to capture the maximum number of points,with as few trades as possible,and with the least amount of risk.

His techniques are based on the premise that markets are not random,but are manipulated in order to allow the main players to buy low and sell high in a repeatable,mechanical system that is observable to the trained eye.He describes a cycle of buying low,selling into a rising market and short selling at the top of a move.From this point the market is sold down to a new buying point and the cycle repeats again.He divided this cycle into 3 days- a buy day a sell day and a short sell day.

The entire strategy is counter intuitive to many traders who wait for "confirmation" of a move before entering,and many enter at exactly the wrong point,and this is what the main players count on.

It therefore follows that the best time to buy is when price is falling.Note not when price begins to fall but as close to the end of the short selling part of the cycle,and as near to the beginning of the buying part of the cycle as possible..So you are looking for a buy point when price looks weak and selling when price looks strong.

Taylor gave very clear (once you have deciphered his writing style) rules on when to look for the buying point and at what price level,and when to sell,where to short sell,and at what price levels.

He also kept what he called a "trading book",where he measured the size of the rally and the size of the decline in order to determine which side of the market the main players were on at any one time.The idea,being,for example,that if the last decline was less points than the previous rally,then those players remained on the long side of the market.In other words,the present decline is a buying opportunity,rather than a reversal of the trend.

How he measured those rallies/declines is not from the most obvious points on a chart.Once you understand how he did this you realise that good information such as this is hidden right in front of you.

Once you have a good understanding of this method you will find yourself taking less trades,more points and staying on the right side of the market more often.

Although this book was written over 50 years ago you can adapt his methods to the modern market and also to your own trading style.

 

I want to invite any traders who are interested in this method,or think they might be interested in learning about this method to take an active part in building this thread into a useful resource.This thread is not intended to be my personal journal- i'm here to gain further insights as much as anyone else on this board.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am into silver and had a weekly range of 0.88 with a total range of 6.28...week had two H2L days which were preceeded by a third one....stayed out till near the low of third and went long from there caught 1.68 so far.....H2L days would have been short opportunities though

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi mitsubishi

Thanks for taking the initiative and the leadership to starting this Taylor Trading Technique thread, its a most welcome opportunity to have you as our guide and teacher as we venture into the mind of George Douglas Taylor. Unknown and unforgotten by most modern day traders as names like WD Gann , Fibonacci and R N Elliott have dominated the headlines. Yet the Taylor method while not as publicized as others, is remarkable accurate in today's market as it was 50 years ago.

 

Not much is know of Taylor or of his private or public life and very few even have a working knowledge of his methodology, whether its because of his incomprehensible style of writing, or perhaps he intentionally wrote in a veiled style of language similar to the veiled writings of WD Gann in his book The Tunnel Thru The Air, so as to keep secret his trading techniques. It seems that 50 years have passed and only a few have been able to comprehend the method hidden in his book, so I am sure that Taylor would be happy to know that his secrets are still well hidden as it is obvious if anyone attempts to read his book on a cursory level only, that within the first few pages they would have lost interest and given up. But the few that have had the patience and the desire to unravel his method will be rewarded with a fascinating and accurate trading method.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

In getting some material together for this thread i am having to re-read Taylor's book,and it still is,in parts,hard going.And,damn,i know the ideas quite well,and yet,i am having to read lines and paragraphs over and again.I can only wonder at how a man can make such simple concepts so tricky to grasp.

All the while you are learning this technique you really have to visualize the chart action that he is talking about,while bearing in mind the previous day's action(s) So i am constructing some diagrams similar to the ones i sketched when first i read this book.

Any reader here new to these ideas needs to appreciate that you cannot get every variation of say,"the buy day" on a single diagram.Taylor's ideas are very logical and simple once understood and it is then the trader's job to apply them in the best possible way according to current market conditions,and most importantly,which side of the market he believes the main players to be on.That part is to do with running your "book" which we will get to later.

So the next 3 diagrams will show the ideal Buy day,sell day and short sell day cycle pattern and then we can deal with the variations.But let us start at the very beginning and that is to begin your cycle count.

The chart below has the explanation for that.

5aa710dac2972_last10days.thumb.gif.3a5ad9b989213170981ac30cd88ea102.gif

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Its interesting that you have 3/6 as a Sell day, in my book which I started back on 11/22/2010 3/6 is a Sell Short day for me and Taylor was right when he said that it does not matter what day you begin the count from so long as you maintain the cycle, because 3/7 would be my Buy day and as it turns out that was the beginning of the up move, now my question on a Buy day, you are supposed to enter at or below the low of the Sell Short day, on 3/6 the low was 1333 but on 3/7 my Buy day the low was 1338.75. So where would I have entered the trade or does it mean that I did not get filled?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi mitsubishi

Just a technical question

When you trade using TTT,are you using a chart?

Do you really need a chart?

regards

bobc

 

That's a great question.How best to answer it? The short answer is i don't need a chart most of the time.Last night i set a limit order to buy this pullback and i have it within a few ticks.So far the market is pretty dull (on my time frame) we haven't taken out friday's high and i'm showing a small profit.What should i do,stare at the screen and watch the bots play tennis?. We need to make a significant move from here to justify another trading decision.All i need to do is keep half an eye on the chart.My "best information" is that the probability remains on the long side,but there is no strength so far.But then,the bears aren't exactly having a field day either.If the situation changes significantly ,i will act accordingly.If you go back to 2008 when we had huge volatility,i was in and out all day,which really isn't my style,but i always think the market shows you what is available and you then try to take best advantage of that.So,of course,then i was glued to the screen.When i was learning,in the early days,i was glued to the screen.

So,if your trading style dictates that you watch the market closely all day,i guess that's what you do,and if not,then you don't.If conditions are such that you need to see how prices are reacting around certain levels,then when those levels are reached you pay close attention.For me there is a lot of "noise" on the chart that isn't tradable

But when you have money in the market,then the market is never far from your mind.No matter how long you play this game,you are constantly reminding yourself, "what is my trading plan?" what are the possible scenarios? is what i'm seeing fitting with expectations? how is my index performing against the Dow,the Nasdaq,is it leading/lagging? What's the balance between adv/decl issues? how is the financial sector performing against the other sectors? Sounds a lot,but really it's just a glance,a quick update,all to answer the question,should i be long short or flat.I am holding long today,and so far there is nothing to tell me to do otherwise.The position is smaller than it would be if we were back at 1340 since some kind of pullback was likely and we have it today.Is this the day that the trend ends and we get the start of a big decline.My best information says it's not likely.

And btw,i glanced at the chart 3 times while typing this....and the song remains the same..so far:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Its interesting that you have 3/6 as a Sell day, in my book which I started back on 11/22/2010 3/6 is a Sell Short day for me and Taylor was right when he said that it does not matter what day you begin the count from so long as you maintain the cycle, because 3/7 would be my Buy day and as it turns out that was the beginning of the up move, now my question on a Buy day, you are supposed to enter at or below the low of the Sell Short day, on 3/6 the low was 1333 but on 3/7 my Buy day the low was 1338.75. So where would I have entered the trade or does it mean that I did not get filled?

 

Another good question,and interesting how your cycle differs from mine.Well the market will do what it wants and in this case it depends on your prior position.If you are flat before the open on the 7th you have to decide if you are going to buy a higher low to get on the continuing trend (long).On that day the open was the low and broke through some early resistance and climbed higher all day ending 2.2 points off the high.So,In short,you are forced to buy a higher low.

What does Taylor say about this? He says that in this case buying a higher low when the main trend is long favours a good rally.That is what you got.For you,this being your buy day,the low came first which is what you want,but the most ideal situation would have been a small pullback at the open to test the prev day low as you said.You would feel safer buying here- a test of a low in an uptrend.

Now let's refer back to this same decision you have to make on the open of the 7th,but this time you are already holding your long from the 6th,so not flat.What does Taylor say about this? He says that if the open is up you have an early opportunity to take your profit and wait for the next days play.Why he says that is because if the market gives you a good profit early you should take it.You don't know for certain that the initial move up on the 7th won't turn out to be the high of the day.

But in the final analysis a trader is his own master and decides what his own personal rules are.Taylor is about working out the probabilities before they occur,taking advantage of them when they happen as expected,and only playing the most favorable setups.

He says don't worry what happens after you get out in terms of profits you left on the table,there is always another play around the corner.So if you got out early on the 7th and closed your long from the 6th it is not the best play to chase the rally that continued all day but rather,to await the short sell play should this rally produce a high early on the short sell day- an ideal short sell play.

Edited by mitsubishi

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mit

In your explanation of the chart in post 5 you said that Taylor says it doesn't matter if two people have different cycles. Could you direct me to the place in his book where he says that? Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mit

In your explanation of the chart in post 5 you said that Taylor says it doesn't matter if two people have different cycles. Could you direct me to the place in his book where he says that? Thanks

 

I will have to find it,give me some time to do that.Are you saying you have a copy of the book and can't find it,or you haven't read it?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mit

 

In your count do you count just day session in the emini ES or do you take into consideration the night session too?

 

Another good question.If my price objective/limit order gets triggered overnight that is a bonus from my point of view.If i am long say,and i'm waiting for a high made first the next day to get out,should that print overnight i will be out.Often,it can print in the 15 minutes after the cash session closes.Taylor says take a good profit when it is offered so i believe i am trading within that spirit,if you like.But i've said elsewhere,the market shows you what is on offer and it is your job to take that in the best way possible.

Regarding your first question,one answer in the meantime is that Taylor says choose a 10 day period and find the lowest low and make that your buy day.He must know that when he writes that,he cannot know which10 day period you will choose,which implies it doesn't matter.But it's important to find the quote if it's there.I will look.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mitsubishi or anyone else, just curious if anyone had any comments on these 2 websites that are offering the TTT service, has anyone ever subscribed for their daily recommendations?

 

Taylor Trading Technique: Trade in Sync with Market Trend

Taylor Trading Technique | TTT E-books | Guide to Trading TTT E-books

 

I have seen these 2 sites before.The first i know nothing about really except to say it doesn't look like a scam site.The second one i believe there is a a user here Richbois who is associated/owns that site and has written on a previous Taylor thread here.The carrot they are dangling (it appears to me) is that more sophisticated means are required to determine which side the main players are on and they have a good system that tells them.I don't know,except for me personally,if ain't broke don't fix it,and second i only rely on my own analysis.The other statistics they list that are on offer really don't interest me personally,i can guess what they are using and my own numbers are pretty reliable.

I do not want to suggest in any way that this isn't a decent service for the money that they are providing.Just saying for me,the only thing i can trust is my own analysis and would feel lost relying on somebody else.I'm in good company since it was a belief held by Jesse Livermore.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

hi Mit, Thanks very much for your comments on the 2 websites, yes I have read the previous thread where Richbios has posted extensively, he is quite knowledgeable on the Taylor method, I actually learned quite a bit from that thread when I started my initial studies on this method. Its about 150 pages long and I believe you were also part of that thread.

 

In the earlier part of my studies I must admit that I became a victim of frustration and just like I wrote in my earlier introductory post, I gave up on the book and it was not until 10 years later which was back in November 2010, I rediscovered the book laying on my bookshelf, so I did a search on this website TradersLaboratory and found that original 150 page thread. It was quite a delight to discover that there was so much interest in the method, that I was inspired to start studying it again and thanks to all the discussions on that thread, I am thankful because of what I learned from everyone that contributed.

 

I am much more comfortable with the material now whereby before I was not able to follow or understand anything that was discussed as it was just too confusing

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
hi Mit, Thanks very much for your comments on the 2 websites, yes I have read the previous thread where Richbios has posted extensively, he is quite knowledgeable on the Taylor method, I actually learned quite a bit from that thread when I started my initial studies on this method. Its about 150 pages long and I believe you were also part of that thread.

 

In the earlier part of my studies I must admit that I became a victim of frustration and just like I wrote in my earlier introductory post, I gave up on the book and it was not until 10 years later which was back in November 2010, I rediscovered the book laying on my bookshelf, so I did a search on this website TradersLaboratory and found that original 150 page thread. It was quite a delight to discover that there was so much interest in the method, that I was inspired to start studying it again and thanks to all the discussions on that thread, I am thankful because of what I learned from everyone that contributed.

 

I am much more comfortable with the material now whereby before I was not able to follow or understand anything that was discussed as it was just too confusing

 

Yes i remember that thread and you saying that in there.I am concerned at this point at the part where he makes up his book.It is incredibly hard to follow.That is the only part where i can find a mention of working out where you begin your cycle.And this is a later revised version i am reading and there is no improvement in his writing skills i can tell you.The tradition of people who can't write producing books is continued within this very forum by a certain psychologist here:fight: what a good debate we had in that thread.I say "we",meaning all other participants except fot the "writer" himself who did a sterling job in completely ignoring me :).Still,at least this guy Taylor was a trader and has some understanding of markets....;)

 

 

To answer Patuca's question,this is what it says.

 

TO MAKE UP TRADING BOOK

(paraphrasing) record the volume high low and close......

"these entries are recorded daily for a period of ten days:then the lowest price reached during this period is ringed and termed a Buying Day."

 

"a trading book started from any date should always be made up in the above manner so that it reads a Buying Day,1st Selling day,2nd selling day..(yet in the contents he calls this A short Sale Day)....then a Buying day,1st Selling Day,2nd Selling Day,then a Buying Day,etc"

 

"The book is always kept in the same order.Never change the continuity from the way it was started"

 

I still conclude from the above that no 2 traders will select the same 10 day period and so will have different cycles.He would have to say the cycle starts on an exact date in time which has to be referred to otherwise.And how would that cover every market? Most of his examples and references are to commodities,cotton,wheat corn,soybeans etc..That is what i originally concluded on first reading the book.Since that time other traders here and elsewhere have all had discussions confirming they have different cycles on the same index,no problems.I have tested changing the cycle from different points in time (i'm sure others would have done so) and have found there is no advantage.Why?

Because the ideal cycle will not trace out repeatedly,for if it did everybody could see it and it would stop working.If everybody wanted to buy the low made 1st on the buy day and sell the high made 1st on the short day who would take the other side?

So the ideal cycle does not always appear regardless of when you start your own cycle.You will run into the variations for which there are rules.They are not too difficult to grasp,and i plan to slowly work through those for all our benefit.

Taylor repeats a lot of what he says,and a lot of the time this makes things no clearer unless you read,re-read,make notes draw diagrams etc.Most of the time it is only a logical variation on the same theme.

But through all of this,you get enough understanding that you can see the simple logic behind it and you adapt the entire method to your trading style and to your knowledge of how your particular trading instrument moves.

Coming back to the book several years after working through that process is where i (we) are now.The thread would be helping all of us if we gain any new insights from revisiting the original source.There is no doubt that for me,this book was a major help in my trading.

The one area i am most concerned about is regarding measuring the rallies and declines.I think i have it right,or whatever i have works according to my backtesting.But that doesn't run as far back as i would like.And that is something i'm going to redress.I measure the decline from the short day high to the buy day low,and the rally from the buy day low to the sell day high.Who else is doing the same,or who is doing that differently?. If you consider that a different cycle starting point would produce a different result how does that work? I am not sure,that is something else to consider.But if having a different cycle starting point doesn't matter then this problem shouldn't be a problem either.

In my version there are 2 pages from Linda Bradford Raschke :"skip chapters 2,3 & 4 completely (How to make up a trading book, Uses for the columns and marks,The symbols as trend indicators) i do not make up a book as Taylor does,nor do i recommend doing so. I do write down the open high low and close and underline the 3 to 4 day swing lows and highs. It helps to keep some type of log by hand,it keeps trading "systematic"

I agree with that last part as i have done something similar since day one.

"Think in terms of concepts instead of specifics"

Again,i agree,that is what this book really teaches you.

I think overall,i have a good grip on the method,but i would like to go over/have more clarity on measuring/comparing rallies/declines,just to be sure i have that part right.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The one area i am most concerned about is regarding measuring the rallies and declines.I think i have it right,or whatever i have works according to my backtesting.But that doesn't run as far back as i would like.And that is something i'm going to redress.I measure the decline from the short day high to the buy day low,and the rally from the buy day low to the sell day high.Who else is doing the same,or who is doing that differently?.

 

I think overall,i have a good grip on the method,but i would like to go over/have more clarity on measuring/comparing rallies/declines,just to be sure i have that part right.

 

That is correct. You have the rallies and declines correct for day trading. You just have to remember that Taylor speaks of using his method to trade 3 different ways. 1) Day trade. 2) Three day trade. 3) Trend trade.

 

In all practicality his category of Day Trade could in fact be a REAL day trade (that is flat at end of day under certain circumstances) or a swing trade where one is flat on the second day of the cycle - Sell day (if a long position had been taken). His category of three day trade is definetely swing trading and the rally goes from buy day to SS day and even at times to next buy day high made first. For instance, if you went long on the buy day and were trading the 3 day method you skip the sell day (i.e. second day of the cycle) and look to get flat on the SSday. However, IF the SS Day closes high then wait and get flat on the next day which will be a buy day with a high made first and the probabilities favor a higher high than the high of the previous day (i.e. the high of the SSday). Taylor labels things different but to make it easy just remember this (using a... going long... senario):

 

Day Trade Method (Most of the book deals with this method) = Flat on second day of the cycle (i.e. the sell day)..in some circumstances flat same day.

 

Swing trade (chapter XIII Three day Trading Method deals with this) = Flat on third day of the cycle (i.e. SS day) sometimes waiting to following by Buy day to get flat.

 

Trend (chap XIV The investor and swing trader and pages 95-97 deal with trend trading which can be weeks or months long) = Flat on successive SS days and Buy days high made first.

 

Much confusion comes when folks don't distinguish between these three methods that Taylor espoused.

 

In essence, the rally from Day trade method is from Buy day to Sell day.

The rally from Swing trade method that Taylor calls Three day method is from Buy day low to SS day high and at times next buy day high made first. The rally for the Trend method (that Taylor sometimes calls swing..hence more confusion) is measured from succesive buy day lows to successive SS day highs and at times succeeding buy day highs when high made first and is higher than the previous SS day high. Those are the measurements.

 

In summary there are 3 different types of declines and rallies. It depends on which of the three methods you are using. Just do 180 on all of it for shorting.

 

I hope this helps and doesn't confuse more????

 

I see here and there more sites springing up using the Taylor method or some hybrid version of it. I guess folks are reading the forums that have articles on it and learning more about it as I find most people don't have the stickability to pull out the gems in Taylors work. Many I think get headaches and quit...way too soon....:)

Edited by WHY?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On the existence of only one true book.....if there were just one book that was right one would assume a fixed relationship between the individual days,i.e if buy day is x then the low on x would have to be X<(xt1) in regard to sell day,this would be a certain fact and also assume fixed relationships in the documented market (selling pressure on x and buying pressure on (x+1)).Since markets are rather chaotic than fixed in general this has me conclude that you cannot find the one and only book.One merely gets a snapshot of ten days and any two individuals with the same snapshot will end up with the same book.Different snapshots....higher likelihood of different books.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

On declines/rallies measured....I document several....

1. From SSH2BDL/BDL2SDH

2. SSH2BDL/BDL2SSH

3. previous day H to L/H to previous L

4. derived from 3 I designate rally and decline parts to singular days to show me buying and selling per day.Their ratio is my measurement of daily buying power.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
That is correct. You have the rallies and declines correct for day trading. You just have to remember that Taylor speaks of using his method to trade 3 different ways. 1) Day trade. 2) Three day trade. 3) Trend trade.

 

In all practicality his category of Day Trade could in fact be a REAL day trade (that is flat at end of day under certain circumstances) or a swing trade where one is flat on the second day of the cycle - Sell day (if a long position had been taken). His category of three day trade is definetely swing trading and the rally goes from buy day to SS day and even at times to next buy day high made first. For instance, if you went long on the buy day and were trading the 3 day method you skip the sell day (i.e. second day of the cycle) and look to get flat on the SSday. However, IF the SS Day closes high then wait and get flat on the next day which will be a buy day with a high made first and the probabilities favor a higher high than the high of the previous day (i.e. the high of the SSday). Taylor labels things different but to make it easy just remember this (using a... going long... senario):

 

Day Trade Method (Most of the book deals with this method) = Flat on second day of the cycle (i.e. the sell day)..in some circumstances flat same day.

 

Swing trade (chapter XIII Three day Trading Method deals with this) = Flat on third day of the cycle (i.e. SS day) sometimes waiting to following by Buy day to get flat.

 

Trend (chap XIV The investor and swing trader and pages 95-97 deal with trend trading which can be weeks or months long) = Flat on successive SS days and Buy days high made first.

 

Much confusion comes when folks don't distinguish between these three methods that Taylor espoused.

 

In essence, the rally from Day trade method is from Buy day to Sell day.

The rally from Swing trade method that Taylor calls Three day method is from Buy day low to SS day high and at times next buy day high made first. The rally for the Trend method (that Taylor sometimes calls swing..hence more confusion) is measured from succesive buy day lows to successive SS day highs and at times succeeding buy day highs when high made first and is higher than the previous SS day high. Those are the measurements.

 

In summary there are 3 different types of declines and rallies. It depends on which of the three methods you are using. Just do 180 on all of it for shorting.

 

I hope this helps and doesn't confuse more????

 

I see here and there more sites springing up using the Taylor method or some hybrid version of it. I guess folks are reading the forums that have articles on it and learning more about it as I find most people don't have the stickability to pull out the gems in Taylors work. Many I think get headaches and quit...way too soon....:)

 

Why,thank you so much for that post.You didn't confuse at all,actually made it very clear.Now i realise why i was concerned whether i had it right.I think what i must have done on first reading (which actually means reading some of it 20 times over :roll eyes:) is that because at the time i was more concerned with shorter time frames in my trading,i pulled out what i needed to fit with that and didn't worry about areas concerning swing trading.Now i do a mixture of both it would be worthwhile getting a better understanding on running the book for longer cycles.I did understand that you could hold through several cycles,but not the part on how to utilize the book with that time frame.

So your post has cleared up that confusion and helped direct focus on the missing part.Much appreciated.Hope you will stick around to keep this thread on the tracks.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On declines/rallies measured....I document several....

1. From SSH2BDL/BDL2SDH

2. SSH2BDL/BDL2SSH

3. previous day H to L/H to previous L

4. derived from 3 I designate rally and decline parts to singular days to show me buying and selling per day.Their ratio is my measurement of daily buying power.

 

That is interesting in that it shows how a trader might adapt Taylor's ideas.My concern on the way you are doing it (not saying it's faulty) is how sure are you that the information you are capturing this way is telling you what you want it to tell you? I'm thinking in terms of what Taylor calls cross currents,the minor swings up and down. Also this:

"With the book trading we are concerned only with the Objective Points and we don't care much whether the price goes straight up or down to reach them." (chapter-1 How The Trend Is Made)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On declines/rallies measured....I document several....

1. From SSH2BDL/BDL2SDH

2. SSH2BDL/BDL2SSH

3. previous day H to L/H to previous L

4. derived from 3 I designate rally and decline parts to singular days to show me buying and selling per day.Their ratio is my measurement of daily buying power.

 

In Taylors book one will find the chapter by George Angel (LSS) which is his adapted version of Taylor. There you will find the rally measurement to be previous days low to todays high. And for the decline previous days high to todays low. One has to understand that this was not any of Taylors measurements at all. Period. It was Angell adapting it to convert the ideas into a pure day trading system where one is most likely flat at the end of the day. While there is some merit to this adaptation it also basically does away with the capturing larger moves. In essence, it is measuring each days strenght or weakness. It isn't necessarily wrong but will throw a monkey wrench into the system when one is averaging the rallies or declines and still trying to capitalize on the manipulation over the course of a three day period cycle such as Taylor tracked. It is also interesting that you no longer find the LSS system for sell (at back in the 90's when I was looking for it it wasn't). That said one can think what they want about Angell but if it wasn't for him most of us today wouldn't have even heard of Taylor. Charles Ballentine, Angell, Linda Rascke, and Joe Ross can all be credited with keeping Taylors ideas alive going in this day and time. And of course without Mr Edward Dobson and Traders Press we probally even wouldn't have a Taylor book to look at except maybe Joe Ross who has a handwritten copy of Taylor.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

The decline/rally concept from Taylor delivers values that are based on two/three consecutive trading days.They represent swings and in that the concept is sound.The delivered information is a compound of the days and eliminates the cross-currents.I was seeking the eliminated information,my idea can be called anti-taylorish in a way I guess.I catch (some of) these cross-currents and the main trend and organise them into buying and selling and compute their ratio.Now I use this to get the daily change in that and compare this information to daily changed volume.I use this only to check market sentiment what turn the next day might bring and not in regard to any objectives.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Mitsubishi,

 

Is Fri the 16th a sell day? ... in the book?

Mit, please can we make midday Friday into a short day?

…and what about Dec 21st?... is that going to be a short day?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Yes, AMP is a good and reliable broker. Almost all FCM brokers and their IBs provide a similar service (the main difference is commission per side or per round, min deposit. Also, margin requirements, but commonly they are similar) Quantower platform allows to trade futures with AMP via Rithmic technology with full market depth data (!)
    • I have never asked for any help here. Never expect a person to be good with me or others. But as Market wizard you should show some respect for others.
    • That is the truth, if you can not accept it then it is not the world problem. Everything you get in this world is having some fees, for that you have to work.
    • Date : 4th December 2019. FX Update – December 4 – Risk Off – 4th December 2019.AUDJPY, H1The Yen has rallied on a safe-haven bid as global stock markets turn lower after President Trump, nearly two months after announcing the limited “Phase 1” trade deal with China, said that trade negotiations may be postponed until after the 2020 presidential election. This after announcing intentions to tariff steel imports from Brazil and Argentina. Disappointing Q3 GDP out of Australia, a country that is highly exposed to the US-China trade, was also in the mix. Growth came in at 0.4% q/q in the antipodean economy, against a median of 0.5%. USDJPY printed a 13-day low at 108.43, while EURJPY and AUDJPY descended into respective one-week low territory and is the biggest moving pair today, down some -0.6%. The Australian Dollar has been the day’s biggest loser out of the main currencies. AUDUSD more than reversed gains seen yesterday on the less dovish than expected RBA statement, in making a low of 0.6814. The AUDJPY triggered lower yesterday on the Crossing EMA Strategy, H1 at 13:00 GMT (1) move down to T1 (2), retraced to Entry (3) to close T2 flat. It then triggered lower again (4) and moved to T1 (5) and T2 (6) for a net move of 47 pips for both legs lower.The Dollar, outside the case of USDJPY, has held firm, finding its own safe haven bid. The sharpest in six months drop in the U.S. 10-year T-note yield yesterday was a reflection of this safe haven bid, which is why forex markets haven’t been trading on yield differential dynamics in the latest phase. Both EURUSD and Cable both drifted moderately lower, before a bid on Sterling saw cable breach 1.3000 and trade over 1.3040 and post a new six month high. Elsewhere, EURCHF has dropped for a third consecutive trading day, this time hitting a three-week low at 1.0923. The decline in the cross have correlated with the prevailing risk-off phase that started at Friday’s release of disappointing U.S. manufacturing ISM data.Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business.Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report.Click HERE to access the full HotForex Economic calendar.Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding on how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE!Click HERE to READ more Market news. Stuart Cowell Head Market Analyst HotForex Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in FX and CFDs products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • Date : 3rd December 2019. Sterling Awaits Election Result – 3rd December 2019. Sunderland South and the direction of Sterling – Why the first constituency to declare its new MP could have a significant bearing on the direction of Sterling on Election night next week. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business. Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report. Click HERE to access the full HotForex Economic calendar. Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding on how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE! Click HERE to READ more Market news. Stuart Cowell Head Market Analyst HotForex Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in FX and CFDs products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.