Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

Recommended Posts

Thursday, 04/22/10

 

I thought this day was somewhat difficult. I tried to apply info garnered from yesterday's posts, in particular:

I preferred to annotate differently that area: pt2 to pt3 decreasing volume.

 

That was very beneficial. Thanks cnms2 and all.

 

Comments appreciated. :)

5aa70ffbaff98_ES06-104_22_2010(5Min).thumb.jpg.33f1c4c30a4597e6d933a9011150ffad.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Hi gucci,

 

Thank you for sharing your valuable volume comparison skills.

 

I have two questions for you---

 

1. You said: you could mentally (or actually) go to a higher (slower) resolution level and compare the highlighted areas---For the 5 minutes ES chart, what's the higher (lower) resolution level you suggest to use according to your observation? Do you mean to switch to10 min,15min, 30min or 60min in this specific

example?

 

2. You said: Furthermore you can compare the transition of the black volume starting after 11:30 - 11:40 area ---The chart under discussion is rs5's which is CST. Does your 11:30 - 11:40 area correspond to Bar 24 to Bar 26? TIA

 

Hi NYCMB,

 

to 1

 

Please understand, I did not suggest any specific resolution. Furthermore I do not think this example was specific. On the contrary this example was rather elementary. Price moves from point 2 to point 3 in a non dominant fashion that is on decreasing volume. It doesn't matter what resolution you chose to compare the aforementioned areas - the volume at point 3 is decreasing.

 

to 2

 

I referred to the chart in cnms2 post, so the times in question correspond to his chart.

 

FWIW.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I would like to share some my experience related to how gain better understanding of this method.

 

I had posted a few daily screenshots on one of the website for Russian’s traders.

 

People started asking question: “What’s this?” “What’s that?”, “Where are entrees, exits?”

 

I say Ok, I will explain it through Skype and shared screen .

 

Most common questions were:

 

- What The P/V Relationship is?

 

- What Gaussian is?

 

- What Tape is?

 

- What Traverse is?

 

- How to they become Channel?

 

- Where are points 1, 2, 3?

 

- How the Left Side of the Market becoming the Right Side?

 

- Why did you enter Long, Short, Reverse?

 

- What Formation is?

 

- Why you hold?

 

- Where Hold button is?

 

- Signal for Change? We never heard of it. Is it secret indicator?

 

And remember: I have to come up with answers in real time.

And people saw what I am doing.

And where price went after I said where it should go.

 

By doing few sessions like that I gain much better understanding and knowledge for myself.

 

My point is - try to explain what are you doing to someone, who really interested to learn this method. It will do great work for you.

 

On the other note, now I understand Spydertrader and admire his multiyear hard work to transfer knowledge to us.

 

Spydertrader,

 

Thank you!

 

Stepan

Edited by stepan7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I received few requests from readers of this thread about teaching, sharing screens etc.

 

Just to be clear. I made few sessions for people from Russia:

 

(1) who have very poor English skills;

 

(2) or their English skills are next to nothing;

 

(3) or they don’t know English at all.

 

None of requestors is falling into any of above three categories.

 

At the end of each session I told folks to take dictionary and read this thread.

 

This thread contains more than enough information necessary.

 

All I can do for requestors just repeat the same thing - read this thread.

 

Stepan

Edited by stepan7

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I am helping a few friends learn the JHM. I think "reading the thread" is right on target as the best advice. In an effort to help myself learn more I also occaissionaly write up a summary or some other exercise. Here is a hack at describing a single fractal of tape drawing with a few items I feel need emphasis. Feeback is always welcome. If I messed up something I am always willing to make a correction or would support having it deleted.

 

Lately I have been studying Jack Hershey's material on IF1 IF2 and APA (including HVS trading). Would some of that material be appropriate here?

 

Thanks to Spyder and the community for the thread and productive interaction.

 

MK

5aa70ffc87dad_MK201004235ESSingleFractal.thumb.png.f30c550aca77c5e0cf1d3b592e6173fb.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
... Feedback is always welcome. If I messed up something ...
Firstly, I believe your volume data contains a few errors. Compare it to rs5's.

Secondly, your pt1 for the up trend doesn't seem right.

5aa70ffc8e29b_2010-04-23volumemkvsrs5.png.ff0cd81f902fd93a4c835c52e8a18492.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks cnms2.

 

I found a code error to explain the volume differences. Fixing that showed peaking volume and a new pt 1. Little things mean a lot!

 

MK

5aa70ffcabaa9_MK201004235ESV2.thumb.png.87a5f51fea88a78755b7dac4dd98b4e5.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

For discussions sake, last Wednesday's chart (RS's revised example) to be correct, we're saying: pt1 to pt2 = pt2 to pt3 = pt3 to VE as far as the fractal level (tape/traverse) they are on. I have a hard time with pt2 to pt3 leg being the same level as the others. Doesn't seem like it has the same components as the others.

5aa70ffcb67b8_4-21-2010ES.thumb.png.363267b151223c5c479aca74fbbbebbf.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For discussions sake, last Wednesday's chart (RS's revised example) to be correct, we're saying: pt1 to pt2 = pt2 to pt3 = pt3 to VE as far as the fractal level (tape/traverse) they are on. I have a hard time with pt2 to pt3 leg being the same level as the others. Doesn't seem like it has the same components as the others.
What do you use to differentiate among fractals? What components are you talking about?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
For discussions sake, last Wednesday's chart (RS's revised example) to be correct, we're saying: pt1 to pt2 = pt2 to pt3 = pt3 to VE as far as the fractal level (tape/traverse) they are on. I have a hard time with pt2 to pt3 leg being the same level as the others. Doesn't seem like it has the same components as the others.

 

IMO, take RS5's thursday's chart, where the last portion of wednesay was revised.

Do you have what you're looking for?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
IMO, take RS5's thursday's chart, where the last portion of wednesay was revised.

Do you have what you're looking for?

 

Thanks, I see the revisions but they don't help with the 11:40 to 12:45 section (10:40 to 13:45 on the posted chart). FWIW, I have 9:50 IBGS on Friday (10:50 on the posted chart) as the new Pt1 up.

 

What do you use to differentiate among fractals? What components are you talking about?

 

Differentiating fractals: Pace level, volume peaks/troughs, and BBT/Tape breaks. On fast to extreme pace levels you might not see the BBT's, the slower pace levels is where they tend to show up.

 

Components for this example: Looking for a complete volume cycle on each leg. Also want to see increasing volume on a tape break or it's a fan with building block tapes within.

 

In summary while I can see your view, and Spyder seems to have verified it, RS's original view is what I had worked out in RT. Feels like I'm having to force the gaussian cycles to see it otherwise. 11:40 to 14:00 looks like is all non dominant 2 to 3 volume, with a full b2b 2r 2b volume cycle.

Edited by Ezzy
typo

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Lately I have been studying Jack Hershey's material on IF1 IF2 and APA (including HVS trading). Would some of that material be appropriate here?

 

 

What does " IF1 IF2 and APA (including HVS trading)" mean please?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What does " IF1 IF2 and APA (including HVS trading)" mean please?

 

There is an if1 if 2 apa strategy report floating around someplace.

 

Here is SCT Report that picks up some of this. I will keep looking and get back here when I find it

sct.thumb.jpg.757520433ae99543ff4b4ebea99cccaf.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

ahhhh ! here is one of them

 

edit: this drawing of IF1 IF2 APA was created by Bi9foot. this is not the strategy report. This is a great drawing and explains well.

 

 

now I remember Ezzy searched extensively for these docs and they did not turn up.

if1_if2_apa.png.7c7e83bb548580428a1191d3b427c583.png

Edited by TIKITRADER

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

HVS = High Volatility Stall JH - Method

 

 

 

quote from Spydertrader

 

A. Hitch

As dominant traverses proceed the price change there is, at first, an almost continuous

advance. Therefore, from bar to bar, the offsets and the bar length repeat one after

another. Progress can soften after a period of time and it shows up as a momentary one

or two bar repeat. Repeat means that consecutive nearly identical bars show up. The

bars often do not have the volatility of the prior advancing bars. Volume will flag

somewhat preceding this phenomena. Then the price resumes its prior advance. The

market has momentarily caught its breath, so to speak.

 

B. Dip

Dips are like hitches only they are more pronounced, meaning that a small noticeable

retrace for one bar may occur. The corresponding volume flagging is more pronounced.

 

C. Stall

Stalls are longer hitches and the volatility may not be less than prior bars. Picture it as a

definite pause and dwell period that occurs not too close to the left fractal channel line.

Volume will oscillate somewhat by flagging and then refreshing and flagging again.

D. High Volatility Stall

This formation usually occurs near the limits of the market’s range and early in the day

when volume is brisk and the market opens somewhat near the prior day’s range. A

high volatility stall can be traded at the rate of one cycle per two bars and it can be

traded in both directions with a neutral bias. The tick length of the bars gives a

comfortable value of profit and leaves room for market fills that may not be at the limits

of the lateral values of the range of volatility in a bar.

Edited by TIKITRADER

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

One of the best sections of all the threads regarding the method can be found starting September 1 2007

 

Spydertrader's Jack Hershey Futures Trading Journal

 

Flaws and Internal Formations

 

beginning about page 884

 

Edit: Attached an old chart from Spydertrader that has an HVS market around 10 to 10:30 am. Reminder . . .Chart is from past with annotations that relate to the discussions taking place at that time.

02-22-2006-es-5min.thumb.jpg.7011055c47c60bcbfdc685788c67d501.jpg

Edited by TIKITRADER

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
What does " IF1 IF2 and APA (including HVS trading)" mean please?

 

TIKI hit the material I was referencing on the money. It is basically the binary logic used to keep you safe when market direction is in doubt (i.e. after a potential FTT until a new trend is verified). IF1 = prepare for a reverse as price passes the previous close against you. IF2 = reverse when price passes the previous bar's extreme against you. Once you execute IF2 or if you reverse/trade for some other reason ON THAT PARTICULAR BAR you then use APA. APA = reverse if price moves against your trade price. You can only do each action once per bar. If you wish, you can then also shift to a faster bar (5' to 1') after APA but only for the duration of the original bar. Then you use IF2 and APA for the remaining time of the original bar using the bars of the faster timeframe. The exception is HVS trading. You stay in the faster timeframe mode until HVS mode is done. Certainly more to talk about but this is a start.

 

I believe it is a part of the mechanics of using the most difficult stuff (Sequences and Signs of Change). Intriguing and harder to implement that you might expect (at least for me).

 

 

I would appreciate any feedback if I got this wrong.

 

MK

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
... Differentiating fractals: Pace level, volume peaks/troughs, and BBT/Tape breaks. On fast to extreme pace levels you might not see the BBT's, the slower pace levels is where they tend to show up.

 

Components for this example: Looking for a complete volume cycle on each leg. Also want to see increasing volume on a tape break or it's a fan with building block tapes within.

 

In summary while I can see your view, and Spyder seems to have verified it, RS's original view is what I had worked out in RT. Feels like I'm having to force the gaussian cycles to see it otherwise. 11:40 to 14:00 looks like is all non dominant 2 to 3 volume, with a full b2b 2r 2b volume cycle.

At 1050 (attached chart), in real time, the blue highlight seems to show a complete (volume, price) sequence on the L2 fractal.

 

I think one difficulty arises from the fact that on the 5 minute chart at different times during the day different market fractals are observable, function of pace. So we can talk about market fractals, observable fractals, trading fractals. I believe that it is very important how we choose the trading fractal (including the sidelining fractal :) ), and it may be more important to emphasize the hierarchy of the observable fractals, than that of the market fractals. In the end we are interested in making money and not in making beautiful charts.

5aa70ffd5a960_4-21-2010ES1050.thumb.png.8409803ea6e2d589d73a4c491a14bd4d.png

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
At 1050 (attached chart), in real time, the blue highlight seems to show a complete (volume, price) sequence on the L2 fractal.

 

I think one difficulty arises from the fact that on the 5 minute chart at different times during the day different market fractals are observable, function of pace. So we can talk about market fractals, observable fractals, trading fractals. I believe that it is very important how we choose the trading fractal (including the sidelining fractal :) ), and it may be more important to emphasize the hierarchy of the observable fractals, than that of the market fractals. In the end we are interested in making money and not in making beautiful charts.

 

I think observable is the key word here. Trying to stick to what is observable on the 5min. There is a lot more to see on each leg on the YM 2min or a 1min ES. For example if you go to a faster time frame, the retraces on the other legs have a full volume cycle. That was missing here (and I can see that on the 5min) which led me to believe it was on a different level.

 

Agree, making money is the end game from all the time spent learning. Thanks for your comments.

 

Regards - EZ

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

  • Topics

  • Posts

    • $AIZ Assurant stock nice breakout, from Stocks To Watch , see https://stockconsultant.com/?AIZ  
    • Date: 28th March 2024. The US Dollar Strengthens As Economists Believe The ECB Will Struggle To “Hold”. Early this morning, the Fed Governor advised “there is no rush to cut rates” and “the data within the upcoming months” will be vital. The US Dollar Index rises to a 1-month high. The value of the USD will largely be based on today’s data on economic growth, consumer sentiment and pending home sales. Dollar and index traders are closely monitoring tomorrow’s Core PCE Price Index which analysts expect will read 0.3%. A higher inflation reading can potentially pressure stocks and support the Dollar. Strong declines in NVIDIA and Netflix stocks pressured the NASDAQ on Wednesday. Though, buyers entered late in the session to boost the overall price. EURUSD The latest comments from members of the Federal Reserve are supporting the US Dollar. The forward guidance between members of the Federal Reserve is mainly not aligned. The Chairman advises the Fed does not need much more proof for the regulator to feel comfortable reducing rates. Whereas the Fed Governor, Mr Waller, advises there is no rush, and he wants to see a few months of data before determining the next move. Therefore, the upcoming inflation and employment data will remain vital and could even push back rate hikes further. According to economists, the Federal Reserve will cut the interest rate on 3 occasions this year, but the timing of the first cut is less certain and may change depending on upcoming data. A positive factor for traders is that EURUSD exchange is not witnessing conflicting currencies. The US Dollar is trading 0.12% higher while the Euro is declining against most currencies. The Euro is trading 0.06% lower against the Pound and the Canadian Dollar and 0.16% lower against the Japanese Yen. Yesterday, the head of the Bank of Italy, Mr Cipollone, said that the authorities were confident that inflation would return to the target of 2.0% by mid–2025. He also supports the lower of interest rate and will use this as a basis for adjusting monetary policy. The Euro is generally under pressure as investors believe the European Central Bank will struggle to avoid cuts if the Fed decide to delay their adjustments. The US Dollar will be influenced by four major economic data releases. The US Final GDP, Weekly Unemployment Claims, Pending Home Sales and Consumer Sentiment Index. If these read higher than expectations with the weekly unemployment claims dropping, the US Dollar is likely to witness further support. However, investors should note the main release will be tomorrow’s Core PCE Price Index. Traders are expecting no major news for Europe and volatility levels may fall tomorrow as European markets are closed for Easter. Technical analysis currently points towards a continued downward trend. The price is trading below the neutral on the RSI and below the 75-Bar EMA. However, investors should note this will also be dependent on upcoming US data. USA100 The price of the USA100 was under pressure throughout the whole US session but was saved by an increased volume of buyers late in the session. However, a positive point is the components held onto their value. Even though the index fell in value, only 28% of the components declined. Investors will now turn their attention towards tomorrow’s PCE Price Index and the upcoming earnings season which will start in mid-April. The price is now trading slightly above the Moving Averages but slightly below the 50.00 on the RSI. Therefore, technical analysis remains at the “neutral” level and continues to indicate a larger price range. If today’s economic data is positive the stock market can witness confidence and support as this continues to indicate a soft landing. Though, if the data is too strong, it could also trigger a hawkish Fed which is known to be negative for the USA100. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business. Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report. Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar. Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding on how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE! Click HERE to READ more Market news. Michalis Efthymiou Market Analyst HFMarkets Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in FX and CFDs products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • $IBKR Interactive Brokers stock narrow range breakout watch above 111.16 , see https://stockconsultant.com/?IBKR
    • $ISRG Intuitive Surgical stock narrow range breakout watch above 403.07 , see https://stockconsultant.com/?ISRG
    • $JETS ETF top of range breakout watch above 20.61 , see https://stockconsultant.com/?JETS
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.