Jump to content

Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.

  • Welcome Guests

    Welcome. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest which does not give you access to all the great features at Traders Laboratory such as interacting with members, access to all forums, downloading attachments, and eligibility to win free giveaways. Registration is fast, simple and absolutely free. Create a FREE Traders Laboratory account here.

jonbig04

Edge VS Mentality

Recommended Posts

Blowfish,

 

I needed to make everything as real as possible so i fooled myself into thinking my paper account was my real account. Using only 1 contract at a time i could feel the rush of making a trade. This is obviously done after i have my strategy in place :cool:For all beggining traders out there treat paper accounts as if they are real accounts. Thats the only way youre gonna learn without losing "real" money. Use it as a educational tool to prepare yourself for the real world.

 

This is one of the best pieces of advice that ANYONE can read. If you new and trying to learn via Demo Trading- Trade it like it is real!

 

I have known people who launched Demo Accounts with far more capital than they could actually ever start their account with in real life- Why? Makes it a pointless excercise IMO.

 

I even talked with one trader while doing Demo's (this was in prep for utilizing a real account- so no time to be fooling around) that decided to buy 100 lots on a currency pair, said "oh it was funny, I was up like a half million and then was down like $1.5 million by the end of the day- it was funny!" I just looked at them and said "Hmm" That was a wasted day to actually learn something if you ask me.

 

Trade it like its real!

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
This is one of the best pieces of advice that ANYONE can read. If you new and trying to learn via Demo Trading- Trade it like it is real!

 

I have known people who launched Demo Accounts with far more capital than they could actually ever start their account with in real life- Why? Makes it a pointless excercise IMO.

 

I even talked with one trader while doing Demo's (this was in prep for utilizing a real account- so no time to be fooling around) that decided to buy 100 lots on a currency pair, said "oh it was funny, I was up like a half million and then was down like $1.5 million by the end of the day- it was funny!" I just looked at them and said "Hmm" That was a wasted day to actually learn something if you ask me.

 

Trade it like its real!

 

 

 

It is real....:)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
It is real....:)

 

You are 100% Correct. I explain to people that even if you are placing trades on a demo- it is the live market, it rips through your emotions of euphoria, fear, indecision, greed and countless others if you sit and watch it with a "live trade" in play.

 

When they still scratch their head at me- not understanding- I say "Look this isn't like a video game- where their is some pre-defined outcome" "Their is no princess to save at the end of the castle- and if you hit the right buttons or jump to the right mushroom- that their is one and only one way to "win the game." The only difference between a $2 Grand Win on a Demo and a $2Grand win on a live account is the fact that you decided to test a theory without risking the money for real- BUT BUT BUT- ONLY if you approach a demo- as if it were real $, you think long and hard about your trades, you plan and execute- just as if their was real $ on the line- not wanting to lose the "fake $" and take it JUST as seriously as if it were real. You'll get pissed if you lose $100 on a Demo, just as if you lost $100 for real!

 

My .02 on that!

Aaron

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
You are 100% Correct. I explain to people that even if you are placing trades on a demo- it is the live market, it rips through your emotions of euphoria, fear, indecision, greed and countless others if you sit and watch it with a "live trade" in play.

 

When they still scratch their head at me- not understanding- I say "Look this isn't like a video game- where their is some pre-defined outcome" "Their is no princess to save at the end of the castle- and if you hit the right buttons or jump to the right mushroom- that their is one and only one way to "win the game." The only difference between a $2 Grand Win on a Demo and a $2Grand win on a live account is the fact that you decided to test a theory without risking the money for real- BUT BUT BUT- ONLY if you approach a demo- as if it were real $, you think long and hard about your trades, you plan and execute- just as if their was real $ on the line- not wanting to lose the "fake $" and take it JUST as seriously as if it were real. You'll get pissed if you lose $100 on a Demo, just as if you lost $100 for real!

 

My .02 on that!

Aaron

 

I have the broken calculator, pencils, and twisted paper clips to prove that it's very much real to me lol:o

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Here is a simple test about the importance of edge vs mentality.

 

Pick a strategy that you know makes money eg open range breakout.

Write down entry , exit and stop parameters.

Trade EXACTLY according to this plan.

Repeat this exact trade 20 times.

 

It will make you money ( not necessarily in the 20 trades ) BUT do you have the mindset to do it?

 

95% of people cannot do this - If you think you can try a demo account if you like. But assess at the end of 20 how you did - and don't lie to yourself.

 

I have been trading full time for 6 years and never found anyone who can get to 20 without "interfering" with it!

 

So the edge is there, but the mentality to follow the chosen plan may prevent someone from adopting the correct behaviour modifications to become a successful trader.

 

What's important is NOT the edge - it's the ability to follow it.

 

For the first 3 years of my trading I thought the edge was the thing and it really isn't. Doesn't stop me constantly striving to develop a better mousetrap however!

 

Just to spur the conversation on however - to follow the plan you have to "own" the edge .... discuss.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Your whole premise is based on picking a winning strategy. "Pick a strategy that you know makes money eg open range breakout."

 

Without that, your mindset is useless. If you don't have a winning strategy and follow the 20 trades exactly per the rules, you will have a great mindset, but still not be profitable.

 

What's important is NOT the edge - it's the ability to follow it.

 

A great mindset, will not turn a losing strategy into a profitable one, esepcially if you follow the rules 100%. You need both. An edge and the ability to follow it. Even your arguement assumed you start with a winning strategy to "test" your mindset.

 

This is like saying to be a Formula 1 champion, you just need to be a good driver and that the car is irrelevant.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I came to conclusion that I cannot develop the proper mindset without consistently profitable strategy. I think that the proper strategy and proper mindset are closely bound together.

The proper strategy is the one you develop yourself, specify it to the least point and thoroughly test it. With this procedure you build the proper mindset - the confidnce in the strategy, flexibilty, readiness, sense for nuances.

I think that wrong mindset is often caused by laziness during building a strategy.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I knew I shouldn't have done this.

 

Let me give you a winning strategy then. This is on the mini Dow.

 

Wait for 60 minutes from the day open.

Buy the breakout, sell the breakdown from the opening range.

 

Put your stop the other side of the range.

Close at end of day.

 

Now I am NOT saying that you will make money in 20 trades - but you certainly should not lose much. Most of the time you should make money (about 97% of the time). Trade it and develop it as you go along.

One thing I do guarantee though - you will be a much better trader at the end of the 20 trades than you were at the beginning.

 

"This is like saying to be a Formula 1 champion, you just need to be a good driver and that the car is irrelevant."

There is a certain misunderstanding here - of course edge is important. You must have a positive expectancy. BUT in my opinion gaining the right mindset has very little to do with edge and is MUCH more important in the long run.

To continue the analogy - this is a lifelong race, winners get to the end, 95% retire or crash- so does it matter if you drive a Mcclaren or a Ford?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Its 50/50.

 

Without discipline, no matter how good the plan, you will fail.

 

Without a plan, no matter how much discipline you have, you will fail.

 

Also, if you have a plan where you're right 7-8 times out of 10 instead of 5/10, I think it's more easy to stay disciplined.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Also, if you have a plan where you're right 7-8 times out of 10 instead of 5/10, I think it's more easy to stay disciplined.

 

"Fail to plan = plan to fail"

 

Also how can you objectively measure how you are doing/ whether you are getting there if you don't know what you want to do ( "make money " is not an objective - 200% gain on capital is).

 

From my minimal research I have found most traders hover around the 50-55% "right" mark. One or two very successful ones average about 40%.

 

I am talking long term averages here.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

 

From my minimal research I have found most traders hover around the 50-55% "right" mark.

 

If that's the case, I'm not surprised that you've "never found anyone" with the necessary discipline.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
If that's the case, I'm not surprised that you've "never found anyone" with the necessary discipline.

 

You'll have to explain that comment dbphoenix.

I myself average 45% "right". You seem to be implying that your average is significantly higher? - if so I take my hat off to you.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
The very successful traders I know are "right" about 30% of the time. Its about profit via R/R. Being right is pointless. IMO

 

Have you personally tried trading something where you're right 50% or less?

I'm sure some traders "with the right mindset" manage to do just fine, but I'm not one of them. And I think that a lot of people would have much less trouble if they could trade something which means being right 80% of the time. Nearly all of the time that means trading less though, and being very very patient. And that's another matter :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Have you personally tried trading something where you're right 50% or less?

I'm sure some traders "with the right mindset" manage to do just fine, but I'm not one of them. And I think that a lot of people would have much less trouble if they could trade something which means being right 80% of the time. Nearly all of the time that means trading less though, and being very very patient. And that's another matter :)

 

ha I'm right WAY less than that!!:rofl: But I'm sure there is no "correct" way, different personalities for different methods etc. However my R/R is what I keep in check so being wrong doesn't bother me.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
ha I'm right WAY less than that!!:rofl: But I'm sure there is no "correct" way, different personalities for different methods etc. However my R/R is what I keep in check so being wrong doesn't bother me.

 

On the other hand, you've only just begun being mentored in whatever it is you're doing, so perhaps you ought to let all of this percolate for several months before drawing any conclusions.

 

Just a thought.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Isn't the win/loss ratio system / edge specific?

Certain systems do just fine at 30% W/L

Others need > 50%, etc

 

Finding just any old edge will not work. The type of system one can 'manage' / 'stick to' / 'implement the appropriate mentality' is determined long before he or she begins trading...One must find an edge that really fits him or her individually - at ‘true nature’ level. That is why I recommend not separating their discovery and development at all… not making one more important than the other because it seems first temporally or in priority.

grasshopper had to grab that pot with both forearms...

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On the other hand, you've only just begun being mentored in whatever it is you're doing, so perhaps you ought to let all of this percolate for several months before drawing any conclusions.

 

Just a thought.

 

 

 

Thats true. Thats what I meant about being right way less than 50% :). However I do believe being right second to being profitable.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
However I do believe being right second to being profitable.

 

Theoretically. But most beginners will find it difficult to stick with a system that's right only 30% of the time, profitable or not. Which is where discipline becomes an issue. Discipline is far less an issue, if an issue at all, working with a system with a hit rate of 60 or 70% or better.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

DbPhoenix

Do you think it's realistic for a beginning trader to find a trading method that is 60% + right? And Profitable?

 

Maybe you have got to that great place with your experience but for a beginning trader I think that is unrealistic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
A great mindset, will not turn a losing strategy into a profitable one, esepcially if you follow the rules 100%. You need both. An edge and the ability to follow it. Even your arguement assumed you start with a winning strategy to "test" your mindset.

 

This is like saying to be a Formula 1 champion, you just need to be a good driver and that the car is irrelevant.

 

 

Thats a great post, and so true. I think its pretty funny how many people focus on "edge" or "mindset" and think they have what they need. The reality is there is no single thing you can do in trading that will make you successful. Its a package deal. You need the whole package to become and stay successful long term in this business.

 

The other thing I think is funny is how people talk about how one thing is more important than the other. Not true in my opinion. Your Formula 1 example is a great, good driver, bad car, still equals loser. You gotta have the whole package.

 

I think there are two types of people, those that focus on what they are good at, and those that focus on what they are bad at. I personally focus on the mental aspect of the trading, because seeing an edge has always been easy for me, but I struggled with the mental/discipline aspect of trading for a while. So thats the part that I must stay ever vigilant with.

 

It sucks to blow out a weeks worth of profits just because you veered from your system and thought you could out-think the market. I have done that in the past, now I have a rule to keep that from happening. I have a post-it note next to my screen that says "Never try something new while the market is open" (I believe I got that gem from a Bill Eng book). What that means to me is if that revolutionary idea pops up during trading, write it down and check it out later to see if its valid. Something that simple has saved me tons of money. Enough here, I am getting off topic.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DbPhoenix

Do you think it's realistic for a beginning trader to find a trading method that is 60% + right? And Profitable?

 

Maybe you have got to that great place with your experience but for a beginning trader I think that is unrealistic.

 

 

I would not get caught up with the percentage right. Whats 60% right today may be 70% right next month, and 40% right the month after that. Things change and go through cycles.

 

The edge that you gave up because it was 35% right could have huge profitability if used with the correct money management. While the edge that is 80% right may only pay out a few tics.

 

Go for the whole package, percentage correct is only 1 aspect of it.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
DbPhoenix

Do you think it's realistic for a beginning trader to find a trading method that is 60% + right? And Profitable?

 

 

Perhaps if beginning traders weren't in such a rush to place their bets and spin the wheel, they'd have a more thorough and practical understanding of what's realistic.

 

But we're already at the point where people aren't reading the thread but beginning again, so what's being said has been said already, and repetition simply makes the thread longer still. So happy trading, everyone. :)

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This thread and it's topic have never been far from my mind. I've been learning a lot in the past few months and I have drawn some conclusions. We all know that a trader needs both discipline and an "edge". But I still hold to my opinion that you really don't have to have much of an edge to make it as a successful trader, you just need to be completely disciplined. It's true that without any edge at all you will never amount to anything, but the simply fact is you don't NEED that much of an edge to be a successful trader. When I say successful, I mean a trader who can make a very good living trading, call it six figures a year. As far as I know, most traders don't do that. Don't get me wrong, my absolute end goal is to be able to read PA like a book and have impeccable discipline, but I maintain that this is an END goal. When I started this thread I scarcely knew any other traders. Now I know a lot of them. I've seen, with my own eyes, a trader make 7 figures in a day. I know traders who average well into six figures a week, I know traders who have never made a penny, and I know traders who average a hundred ES points a week on SIM, but can't make a dime cash. I know all kinds of traders! And its great because I can really take an objective step back and see where the problems are. The truth is very few hard working, PA based traders are making consistent good money trading. Despite the fact that they seem to know every kind of PA formation and can spot things that I could never see. To me its almost as if they are trading to learn PA, as opposed to making money. I'm learning to trade to make money. PA is just a vehicle on that road to profitability. It seems like a lot of traders are so bogged down because they are trying to "master" PA and its every aspect. Why? Why not just develop a system that makes, say 5 ES points a week, consistently week after week. Laugh if you want, but just do some basic arithmetic and if you slowly build your capital, you will find that soon 5 points a week trading hundreds of contracts can be pretty lucrative indeed.

 

While its true a lot of traders fail because they are looking for a shortcut in indicators, and don't want to put together a system and are basically...lazy. I really tend not to focus on those because it seems to me a lot of hard working traders are out there making no money. And I really believe that's because they spend their time trying to master PA as a whole, instead of using PA to eek out a slight edge and then maintain complete discipline in order to heavily capitalize off of that edge. Sure I want to master PA too, but for right now I just want to make a couple hundred thousand a year from home and to do that, all I need is slight advantage and complete discipline. When we get there THEN we can start trying to quantify every nuance of PA.

 

Maybe I'm wrong and all my peers are making six figures a year already, but I don't think so. If you aren't, yet you manage to make a few points a week consistently may I ask why?

 

Just my $0.02.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Topics

  • Posts

    • Date: 29th March 2024. GBPUSD Analysis: The Pound Trades Higher But For How Long? The global Stocks Markets are closed due to Easter Friday (Good Friday). The NASDAQ continued to follow the sideways trend while other indices again rose. The SNP500 reaches an all-time high, but the NASDAQ remains under pressure from Tesla, Meta and Apple. The Euro continues to trade lower against all major currencies including the US Dollar, Euro and Japanese Yen. The British Pound is the best performing currency during this morning’s Asian session. However, investors are largely fixing their attention on this afternoon’s Core PCE Price Index. GBPUSD – The Pound Trades Higher but For How Long? The GBPUSD is slightly higher than the day’s open and is primary due to the Pound’s strong performance. At the moment, the British Pound is increasing in value against all major currencies. However, the US Dollar Index is also trading 0.10% higher and for this reason there is a slight conflict here. If investors wish to avoid this conflict, the EURUSD is a better option. This is because, the Euro depreciating against the whole currency market avoiding the “tug-of-war” scenario. The GBPUSD is trading slightly lower than the 2-month’s average price and is trading at 49.10 on the RSI. For this reason, the price of the exchange is at a “neutral” level and is signalling neither a buy nor a sell. The day’s price action and future signals are possibly likely to be triggered by this afternoon’s Core PCE Price Index. Analysts expect the Core PCE Price Index to read 0.3% which is slightly lower than the previous month but will result in the annual figure remaining at 2.85%. The PCE rate is different to the inflation rate and the Fed aims for a rate between 1.5% to 2.00%. Therefore, even if the annual rate remains at 2.85%, as analysts expect, it would be too high for the Fed. If the rate increases, even if only slightly, the US Dollar can again renew bullish momentum and the stock market can come under pressure. This includes the SNP500. Investors are focused on the publication of data on the UK’s gross domestic product (GDP) for the last quarter of 2023: the quarterly figures decreased by 0.3%, and 0.2% over the past 12-months. This confirms the state of a shallow recession and the need for stimulation. The data, combined with a cooling labor market and a steady decline in inflation, increase the likelihood that the Bank of England will soon begin interest rate cuts. In the latest meeting the Bank of England representatives did not see any members vote for a hike. USA500 – The SNP500 Rises to New Highs, But Cannot Hold Onto Gains! The price of the SNP500 rises to an all-time high, before correcting 0.33% and ending the day slightly lower than the open price. Nonetheless, the index performs better than the NASDAQ which came under pressure from Tesla, Meta and Apple which hold a higher weight compared to the SNP500. For the SNP500, these 3 stocks hold a weight of 9.25%, whereas the 3 stocks make up 14.63% of the NASDAQ. The SNP500 is also supported by ExxonMobil’s gains due to higher energy prices. The market will remain closed on Friday due to Easter. However, the market will reopen on Monday for the US and investors can expect high volatility. Investors will also need to take into consideration how the PCE Price Index and the changed value of the US Dollar is likely to affect the stock market next week. Always trade with strict risk management. Your capital is the single most important aspect of your trading business. Please note that times displayed based on local time zone and are from time of writing this report. Click HERE to access the full HFM Economic calendar. Want to learn to trade and analyse the markets? Join our webinars and get analysis and trading ideas combined with better understanding on how markets work. Click HERE to register for FREE! Click HERE to READ more Market news. Michalis Efthymiou Market Analyst HFMarkets Disclaimer: This material is provided as a general marketing communication for information purposes only and does not constitute an independent investment research. Nothing in this communication contains, or should be considered as containing, an investment advice or an investment recommendation or a solicitation for the purpose of buying or selling of any financial instrument. All information provided is gathered from reputable sources and any information containing an indication of past performance is not a guarantee or reliable indicator of future performance. Users acknowledge that any investment in FX and CFDs products is characterized by a certain degree of uncertainty and that any investment of this nature involves a high level of risk for which the users are solely responsible and liable. We assume no liability for any loss arising from any investment made based on the information provided in this communication. This communication must not be reproduced or further distributed without our prior written permission.
    • MT4 is good and will be good until their parent company keep updating the software, later mt4 users will have to switch to mt5.
    • $SOUN SoundHound AI stock at 5.91 support area , see https://stockconsultant.com/?SOUN
    • $ELEV Elevation Oncology stock bull flag breakout watch , see https://stockconsultant.com/?ELEV
    • $AVDX AvidXchange stock narrow range breakout watch above 13.32 , see https://stockconsultant.com/?AVDX
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

By using this site, you agree to our Terms of Use.