[sunilrohira]

Power555 and I decided to open a new thread to discuss Jurik Indicators. We hope to post some charts and invite discussion on other members experiences on these indicators.

[Tams]

MA comparisons

credit: robotman at
TS SUPPORT :: View topic - Jurik Tools for MC- good news and bad news

[HAL9000]

Hint: It's yellow.

And finally, its still about money/trade management.

My problem are mainly stops,
but maybe I have already overcome this issue.

Anyway, somehow its seems to me,
that if you are not able to trade one line (lagging or not?!)
more lines may be more difficult.

Excuse me, and best wishes for your thread.
This indicator itself, seems to be a good one.


Regards,

Hal

[Power555]

Hey Tams-

The jpegs above seem to referennce the Juriks AMA which was replaced and greatly improved by the JMA.

Additionally, the inputs for the "*BP AMA", which I assume you refer to as Juriks, do not match the AMA input selections from Jurik.

Could you post the code, please? Then I could verify its accuracy.

Thanks!

[Tams]

Originally Posted by Power555 »

Hey Tams-

The jpegs above seem to referennce the Juriks AMA which was replaced and greatly improved by the JMA.

Additionally, the inputs for the "*BP AMA", which I assume you refer to as Juriks, do not match the AMA input selections from Jurik.

Could you post the code, please? Then I could verify its accuracy.

Thanks!

Those are not my charts.
pls see link in my post for original creator.

I am re-posting these charts for general interest,
and as a point for discussion only.

[Power555]

Originally Posted by Tams »

Those are not my charts.
pls see link in my post for original creator.

I am re-posting these charts for general interest,
and as a point for discussion only.

Is your intent to support this thread and its discussion of code for Jurik indicators?
The periods of the MA's on the JPEG vary from 3 to 10. Not a valid comparison at all.

[Tams]

Originally Posted by Power555 »

Is your intent to support this thread and its discussion of code for Jurik indicators?
The periods of the MA's on the JPEG vary from 3 to 10. Not a valid comparison at all.

depends on what you want to compare,
fixed period of MA "A" vs MA "B" ?

or see how a specific MA can approximate its price movements
and to see its ability to smooth out the noise and filter out the false signals?

you can use a fixed period as a starting point of comparison,
but it really does not lend much value to a smoothing end result,
because each MA goes through different iterations in its calculations.

[FulcrumTrader]

BTW, of the few indicators I do use in my trading, I do like the Jurik JMA & VEL tied into my Cumulative Delta candlesticks for scalp entry set up reference points.