| Technical Analysis The technical discussion forum for traders. |
![]() | | Tweet | |
| | #1113 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship We have had some slow markets in the past few weeks. Does anything change in your approach to annotation as the market volume slows? I could make a case for changing the time frame for both ES and YM and using longer timed bars. Or drop down to faster bars. Is one change better than the other; or is annotation always the same regardless of the market movement? Thanks in advance for any comments. ramora | ||
| |
|
| | #1114 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship Quote:
can you post your chart to show your reasons for the need to change? can you make the change, then show us another chart? is it better after the change? do you see any improvements?
__________________ ..........This is a terribly difficult question to answer. The only satisfactory answer is: "It depends"... Last edited by Tams; 12-20-2009 at 12:04 AM. | ||
| |
|
| | #1115 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship Quote:
| ||
| |
|
| | #1116 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship In an effort to contribute to the JHM community as so many others have, I have put together a summarry of the material I found most helpful since I started reading this thread. I may have made errors in the presentation or even still have errors in my understanding of some of the concepts, so view critically. In either case, your feedback is welcome. Please remember that this my humble attempt to present material I am still learning. The words are mine and not Jack's or Spyder's. Hopefully I am helping and not hurting. The presentation was built in PowerPoint and exported as a Word document. If another form is desireable, let me know. I also included the original .png of the screen capture I used as an example. Good learning. MK | ||
| |
|
| The Following 16 Users Say Thank You to MKTr For This Useful Post: | ||
become (12-21-2009), ChiefE (12-20-2009), clmacdougall (12-20-2009), frenchfry (12-21-2009), getzil (12-21-2009), Gregor_S (12-21-2009), NYCMB (12-21-2009), padrotshik (12-21-2009), patrader (10-20-2010), ramora (12-20-2009), rs5 (12-20-2009), sezor (03-28-2011), sscott (10-29-2010), Stevecs (10-20-2010), Tams (12-20-2009), TIKITRADER (12-20-2009) | ||
| | #1117 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship Quote:
| ||
| |
|
| The Following User Says Thank You to TIKITRADER For This Useful Post: | ||
MKTr (12-20-2009) | ||
| | #1118 | ||
![]() | Re: Comments on document Quote:
On page 6 at the bottom on the left, I think the 2b of the faster fractal b2b2r2b gaussian of the B2B looks strange. On page 3 the sine waves of P and V, I would move the volume sine wave a quarter to the left to reflect the volume peaks happening at the price peaks or middle point of two adjacent price peaks. That is how I see JH and others positioned the waves. Correct me if I am wrong. Merry Christmas! SK0 | ||
| |
|
| The Following User Says Thank You to SK0 For This Useful Post: | ||
MKTr (12-21-2009) | ||
| | #1119 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship Thanks for the feedback. Yes, I messed up the phase of the price/volume sine waves. I fixed that. I stand by the faster fractal under B2B. Keep in mind it is just an example. I am sure there areas for improvement that remain. Here is the corrected presentation. Please disregard the previous. The original .png sample drawing reamins good. (as good as I can produce) MK | ||
| |
|
| The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to MKTr For This Useful Post: | ||
clmacdougall (12-21-2009), Gregor_S (12-21-2009), rs5 (12-21-2009), Tams (12-21-2009), TIKITRADER (12-21-2009) | ||
| | #1120 | ||
![]() | Re: The Price / Volume Relationship Feedback is always welcome. Merry Christmas. MK | ||
| |
|
| The Following 5 Users Say Thank You to MKTr For This Useful Post: | ||
Gregor_S (12-21-2009), padrotshik (12-22-2009), rs5 (12-21-2009), Tams (12-21-2009), TIKITRADER (12-21-2009) | ||
![]() |
| Tags |
| channels, gaussian, pice volume relationship, trend lines, volume sequences |
| Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
| Display Modes | |
| |
| ∧ Similar Threads | ||||
| Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
| Volume and Price Setups | Soultrader | Technical Analysis | 7 | 02-01-2012 11:52 AM |
| Basic Economic Theory Model to Explain the Volume and Price Relationship | zkreso | Technical Analysis | 4 | 07-12-2009 11:14 AM |
| Can Price Move Without Volume? | gabroo_munda | Beginners Forum | 25 | 06-28-2009 09:40 PM |
| Charts with Volume by Price | bertg | Beginners Forum | 28 | 03-31-2009 10:58 PM |
| [Volume Analysis at Key Price Levels] | Soultrader | Trading Videos | 4 | 03-12-2007 05:38 PM |