[Dogpile]

This thread is to discuss Swing Trading from a George Taylor perspective.

[Dogpile]

So today looks big and scary. But actually, we are in 'balance'. This kind of day reminds me of the big down days last August. big down move, sideways chop for a few hours until 40k+ contracts build up at a single price... then trend away in the afternoon from VWAP. note that:
Price=VWAP=PVP <--- this signals 'balance. From balance comes a directional move.

I am look for a trending move away from 1532.50 of ~10 pts, perhaps more

so, break up could lead to 1542.50+
break lower could lead to 1522.50

note we could break one way, do a trap and then rocket the other way. This would be most evident if we make a 'higher low' after breaking lower.

a break in one direction should not return to 'accept' the VWAP price -- it should break and trend away so this should be a clue that a trap may have just occured.

[RAVIN]

Well quite a drop on the Dow yesterday, can be considered as a SS day, in which case today would be a buy day. Basically I have lost the TT count

OTOH as per Linda Raschke, today is most likely to be zig zag day, i.e narrow range day, testing of lows of yesterday is the place to watch.

[Dogpile]

My version of monitoring Taylor concepts:

Week in Review:



I have plotted at the bottom what I think is a helpful indicator to help with 'location'. This has to do with 'location'. Thus, I have plotted an indicator that shows where price is starting the day relative to the 15-min 20 period exponential moving average. The market will 'test' this 15-min 20ema almost every day. One idea is to counter-trend trade the morning session (like Taylor did) if the market is starting FAR away from the 15-min 20ema. This cannot be taken in isolation -- it depends on the last few days of action but this is a good additional indicator to think about as you review the action going on, IMO.

So here are my concepts to monitor:

1) do you have a high or low 'violation' (violation of previous day high or low)?
2) what has been the recent action (last few days) in terms of trading 'high to low' or 'low to high' (this is the first indicator)
3) is price starting the day FAR away from the 15-min ema?

If you have had 1 to 2 'High to Low' days, then a low violation with price starting far away from 15-min EMA, be careful of shorting and consider the long-side.

[RAVIN]

Thanks Dogpile,
It is beginning to sound more logical now. You are right about getting the concepts right rather than focussing on the labels (buy day or ss day etc).

o.k now we have 2 days of High to Low, hence for 5-11, Monday's probable price action, we should be looking for a Low violation to go long.

[Dogpile]

o.k now we have 2 days of High to Low, hence for 5-11, Monday's probable price action, we should be looking for a Low violation to go long.

that is right. however, given the location of the close relative to the intraday low, we seem unlikely to get that 'low violation' as we are actually closer to a 'high violation' than a 'low violation' given the closing price.

note we made an afternoon 'higher low' as there appeared to have been a wall of buyers down near 1503.00. when you build up a lot of volume low in the recent range and form a late afternoon 'higher low' --- this generally means the market will attempt to auction up next -- which aligns nicely with the 2 recent 'high to low' days.

So we are in the situation of having a bullish bias but we might get a 'high violation' first, which for Taylor is short-term bearish. Thus, what do you do?

Plan B would set-up something like this (keep in mind Fridays closing price of 1517.75):

1) You get a high violation above 1520.50 into the mid-1520's, call it 1525.

2) 15-min 20ema closed near 1511 -- thus a big premium to that is short-term bearish as we tend to move back towards this EMA IF we start out really far away from it. 1511 + ~13pts = 1524.00 --- this might be a shortable level. (Note 15-min EMA will be moving up so call it 1524-1526 zone for now)

3) You look at support/resistance: this is not super clear but I do see a lot of past volume occured in the 1530-1532.50 zone. 1525-30 has been very 'noisy' (tricky) as well.

So if we trade directly up toward 1525-30 area, I would not want to be long and would consider a short but only for a short-term trade back towards the 15-min 20ema. (note this is just in the morning, as Taylor likes to stress looking for 'morning reversals' on tests of key levels). If trades into 1525+ zone, right away -- then we 'could' have a 'high made first' and make the high for the day there. We also might just need to trade down from there to test lower before going back up for a 'low to high' day. But either way, the location slightly favors shorting there.

The better trade would be for it to trade back down towards the '15-min 20ema' and then potentially go long in hopes of a 'low to high' day. This is consistent with 2 high to low days, the Friday buying that occured low in the recent range and buying on a correction would be consistent with buying a 'higher bottom' vs Fridays low --- Taylor talked a lot about buying 'higher bottoms'.

Thus my initial gameplan is:
Look to be a buyer on Monday as the day looks to have a constructive set-up,
but
in back of mind, consider a short if the market starts out 'too high' and play for a short-term trade back towards the 15-min ema - then potentially look long.

I think this thinking is similar thinking to Taylors core concepts of:
'buying a higher bottom'
and/or
'buy day, high made first'

After that initial gameplan, its about reading the intraday action.

[waveslider]

Hey Dogpile, When taylor was around there wasn't a VWAP.
During the past 10 years it seems like VWAP has gotten more and more attention, and become a real psychological point that many traders watch.
I have been watching a modified idea of Taylor's, using the VWAP instead of highs and lows.
The idea is that following a buy or sell day (for our interpretations here, a low to high day or high to low day respectively) should come a test and rejection of the previous day's VWAP.
Does this spark any ideas?

[Dogpile]

Does this spark any ideas?

I am watching VWAP to help read 'the tape'. Reading the tape was a crucial aspect to Taylors trading as he said it over and over again.

A few rules of thumb I use to keep you out of trouble:

If price is spending even 'some' time above VWAP -- then the day is likely not that bearish. A big correction is probably a buy.

I also find it a nice reference level in terms of 'todays vwap' vs 'yesterdays closing vwap'. If todays VWAP is greater than yesterdays closing VWAP value, then a good correction is also a buy.

If todays VWAP is less than yesterdays VWAP and price is not strongly rejecting the current day VWAP, then the market is again, likely a buy.

These rules of thumb keep you looking long most of the time.

The only time to look short then is when price is strongly rejecting VWAP AND vwap is building less than yesterday VWAP. These are those really bearish days to be short.

This doesn't mean can't short other select times (for instance I also like shorting a 'high violation' into resistance -- in the morning session (regardless of VWAP).