Welcome to the new Traders Laboratory! Please bear with us as we finish the migration over the next few days. If you find any issues, want to leave feedback, get in touch with us, or offer suggestions please post to the Support forum here.
winnie
-
Content Count
141 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Everything posted by winnie
-
Dear DbPhoenix, According to your experience, could Wyckoff method be use in day trading ? thanks
-
Thing very clear ! Thanks
-
Dear Sledge, Thank for your advice. Would you tell me which one is the test bar ? Would you point it out to make it more clear ? Anyway your advice is very helpful. Thanks
-
Dear Sir, Could you point out where you see this ? " At A, there was good stopping volume over three bars.Note how the lows refused to go lower - a shortening of the thrusts on increased volume ("bag holding") " thanks
-
Dear mister ed, If you buy near the low of my chart , how would you management your position by using wyckoff method in your time frame. I wonder wyckoff method could only be use in long term trading ? Could it be use in day trading ? any suggestion Thank you for your time Winnie
-
Thank you for your kind advice. It is very useful. The chart is come from Interactive Brokers which is free. Thanks again
-
My 15 minutes chart:crap::crap:
-
Dear Sir, I enter at the Red Candle ,which is 3 bar left to the low. I enter because I see the volume is low when compare with the previous up bar. I think the selling pressure is not strong. Thus I enter at the close of the bar, and put my stop at the low of the day. My profit target is using "Market On Close " order as I think I should catch the day low. Then next 2 bar move up with increasing volume and suddenly the red bar hit my stop and then move up ! Thanks for your kind help
-
Dear Mister Ed, Thank for your reply. I don't know how to insert an image. Take yesterday ES 15 minutes chart as an example. My support zone is 1407-1410. When market test 1409, the down volume decline and then a up bar formed. I enter the trade at a retest with down bar with low volume. Then market go up with higher volume. However, suddenly market drop down and hit my stop point with big volume. After killing my stop , it go up again ! I know there is no holy Gail, but just want to share the idea. Hope anyone can post a 15 minutes chart of ES
-
Dear sir, I find that it is hard to use VSA method in monitor each bar. There seems to be a lot of noise in it. However, I do not know how to tail my position , after entry. Is there any suggestion ? thanks
-
Is anyone could tell me where I could get some information on Mr.Richard Wyckoff method ? Any books or web site about it ? Thanks for your kind help
-
Is anyone could tell me where I could get some information on Mr.Richard Wyckoff method ? Any books or web site about it ? Thanks for your kind help
-
It is my pleasure to say thank you to all you. It is really helpful.
-
Dear BearBull, Thanks. This is what I see in real time. This make me very confuse in how to use VSA in actual trading. I don't know which bar to trust.
-
Dear All of you , Thanks for all your kind help. VSA is a very new thinking to me. I need to gain more experience and more stud:cheers::cheers:y on it. Anyway all of your advise is very useful and make thing more clear ! Best Wishes for profitable trading !
-
Dear Gary, I am new to this VSA concept. However, I do not understand that how a big range bar with strong volume can be create by 'no demand '. This make me a little bit confused. As Tom Williams always said that big volume and big range bar is not good for the trend to continue. Thanks for your kind help.
-
Hi DbPhoenix Your post is to the point ! The point is how do we know the up Bar with strong volume is trend continue or a trap ? I agree that we cannot counter the trend every time you see a big volume and a big range bar. I agree that a "no demand bar is not enough" otherwise we will always counter the trend .However ,What is the obvious signal to confirm it is a trick ?
-
Yes, this is a very new concept. Before that, I always looking for a strong up bar with big volume to long the market ! I always buy the high and then the market drop down ! However, evey technical books recommend to look for volume to confirm the buy signal !
-
Dear Zdo, Thank you for your advise. Do you mean when the "Smart Money" is selling with big volume in a up Bar, actually the non-professional are buying ? However, while the bar close at the top ? Does it means the non-professional 's buying power is very strong ? otherwise the price cannot close at the high of the bar.
-
I have read the book " Master the Markets ". In the book , it said that when the bar is up with big volume and follow by a down bar , the market is near the top. It said that the "smart money" is actually selling in the big volume , big range bar. However, it make me confuse that how the "Smart money" selling with such big range up bar ? If they are selling , how do the bar go up with big volume and up close ? Thanks.
-
Dear Sir, I am really new to VSA method, and find it seems very useful in confirming signal in my Market Profile Analysis. Is there any books or material , I can learn some basic idear about such method ? Thanks for all your kind help
-
Dear Frank, Have you find out that in the afternoon period , there is always new intraday high or new intraday low ? Thanks for sharing your study .
-
Thanks for sharing your view
-
Dear Frank, yes, the laggards are in signal this morning ! thank you. After today's close, the market seems to be "balanced". Do you mean we can buy low , sell high in this case ? Is there any trend now ? Thank you Master !
-
Dear Frank, According to your experience, could you trade everyday ? That mean everyday you could draw conclusion in the market ?