[traden4x]

Originally Posted by OAC »

I have a lot more tips if you promise to keep them off your next book.

OAC,

Hey the suspense is killing!!!

So what are the tips?

Cheers,
Carl

[OAC]

Originally Posted by traden4x »

OAC,

Hey the suspense is killing!!!

So what are the tips?

Cheers,
Carl

I gave you a link, "trade what you see", much earlier in this thread. There is some very good stuff in there. But you brushed it off as being too ordinary,

[traden4x]

Originally Posted by OAC »

I gave you a link, "trade what you see", much earlier in this thread. There is some very good stuff in there. But you brushed it off as being too ordinary,

Sorry there OAC, you made the comment about a "special sauce" if you will. I asked about it and you give this kind of response. FYI I did goto your link and looked around and guess what? 99.99% of it is typical price action. OK that is fine as that is what I trade.

Was my question to your baited post a reason to be snotty about it? I thought maybe this forum would be a better place to work and trade through. I guess that still remains to be seen.

Cheers,
Carl

[suriNotes]

Hi OAC,

Today I plotted X5 patterns using 10000 shares of @ES chart.
Here is the pic.. I'll watch next week or so and let you know if
they have an advantage.

Regards,
Suri

Originally Posted by OAC »

Suri,
Tim Morge, the Median Line expert uses 10,000 volume bars for the S&P.
And our local expert, Steve46 uses 2400, 10,000 volume bars for his pattern recognitions.
Do you find any value in volume bars in your work with Harmonics ?

Thanks and Welcome Aboard

[suriNotes]

Here is the same X5 pattern chart on 610 Tick of @ES.
The price-swing ratios are pretty identical (should be) but
the number of bars may be different.

In tradestation's RadarScreen, I cannot compute my
BarInfo analysis (Num. of Bars, Avg. Bar Range) for
a Volume Chart (no options provided in RS).

I'll watch in real-time next few days
and see if 610T chart and 10000 shares
chart produce the same X5 patterns, then I may stay
with my 610T Chart.

Here is a similar box-range Renko chart showing
X5 pattern structures.

Regards,
Suri

[OAC]

Check out this post I made back in 1-21-2008: http://www.traderslaboratory.com/for...re-3230-2.html
It is interesting looking back on it now.
I was trying to identify Harmonic pattern and price and time symmetry in the Dow. And I was probably the first person on this forum who mentioned the two unfamiliar words back then: "Derivative Meltdown". It is a little scary to have something that was somewhat theoretical to become a full-blown reality in a matter of a few month.
On the other hand, none of this matters as a trader/scalper that I am now. Every day, every hour and every second, I have or try to have no opinions. Zilch. Nada. I enjoy my soundful sleep every night and even take occasional naps during the day.