[walterw]

Originally Posted by unicorn »

Hello Walter;

In another thread you mentioned that you believe 22 tick charts are the best or the most appropriate. That was for the Russel.
I have a couple of questions.

Q1: Would you please comment on the 22 tick chart being the most appropriate for viewing price action.
Q2: Your thoughts about the 110 tick - 22 tick chart on forex (futures).

The first chart has basically the same structure as the time based.
The second chart has cleaner price action; the magenta line rejection on the 5 min chart has been transformed to good momentum (WIDE RAINBOW) on 110 tick chart and a magenta line rejection on the 22 tick chart.

Please mark your entry and exit on the charts.

best regards.
Unicorn.

As I am on mt4 , I dont have tick charts... sure tick charts are clean... but I would not use 22T on this case as I see it too noisy for this aproach...

I like what the 110T chart gave you with ccit3 timings :






unfortunately we still dont have a programer to do Pyenners Formulas on Ninjatrader platform, as it has tick charts and its also a free platform... hope we get there sometime... cheers Walter.

[walterw]

Originally Posted by unicorn »

cyan Line is: vmar_1(ema_periods=3, adx_periods=3)

black line is: ema( vmar_1(3,3), ema_periods=3)

Please note that I am using the full Vidya implementation as initially described by Tushar Chande in his book; where the Adaptive ma (AMA) coefficient = (ema coefficient) multiplied by the (stochastic adx).

i.e.

function Vidya_adx(adx_bars, ema_periods )
{
g = ADX(adx_bars);

adx_min = LLV(g, adx_bars ) ;
adx_max = HHV(g, adx_bars ) ;

diff = adx_max - adx_min;
stoch_adx = IIf( diff != 0, (g - adx_min) / diff, 0 ) ;

f= 2/( ema_periods+1);

coefficient = f * stoch_adx;
zVidya=AMA(C, coefficient);
xvidya = MA(zvidya,2);

return xVidya;
}

thanks for this info Unicorn.

[unicorn]

Originally Posted by walterw »

I also like to see how nice you are blending the "vmar icons" setups with the timing method of "vma trend scalps" ... this two ccit3`s work very nice, they do an excellent timing job...

Walter,

I think you will like these as well.
Your comments and annotations will be appreciated.

Cheers. Unicorn.

[Sparrow]

Walter, I really love your video's and your humor, thanks for sharing so much of your work.

I ported the FantailVMA to NinjaTrader, it can be found here.
Porting was pretty easy and results look good, although I wouldn't know if it's 100% accurate.

[walterw]

Originally Posted by Sparrow »

Walter, I really love your video's and your humor, thanks for sharing so much of your work.

I ported the FantailVMA to NinjaTrader, it can be found here.
Porting was pretty easy and results look good, although I wouldn't know if it's 100% accurate.

Thats great Sparrow, I will take a look at it... do you know if ccit3 could be programed also ? ... that would be so nice ¡¡

Thanks for encouragment Sparrow ¡¡ cheers Walter.

[Sparrow]

It looks like a couple of hours work, the indicators themselves aren't very difficult to code. Unfortunately I am busy at the moment but I am sure I can post something in the next few days.

Cheers

[unicorn]

Originally Posted by walterw »

I would not use 22T on this case as I see it too noisy for this approach...

Noisy? Why?
Walter please elaborate. I have not used tick charts that much; I would like your point of view.

currency Futures in the interval 02:00 EST - 07:00 EST do not have much volume; tick bars are forming slowly; that's why I picked 22T.

Do you get better information from the 55T?

[walterw]

Originally Posted by Sparrow »

It looks like a couple of hours work, the indicators themselves aren't very difficult to code. Unfortunately I am busy at the moment but I am sure I can post something in the next few days.

Cheers

There is no hurry Sparrow ¡¡ it will be cool to see how we can also have this great indicators on NT.. I am very greatfull for your collaboration on this ¡¡

thanks a lot ¡¡ cheers Walter.