TraderDNA Portal - Feedback Welcome

[Soultrader]

Dear Traders,

A while back we were under development to try to implement a TraderDNA portal within Traders Laboratory. Recently this project has been brought back and would like to seek some feedback from traders before making any implementation. So what is TraderDNA? TraderDNA is an analytical reporting service that allows traders to analyze their trades in detail. I have attached a sample pdf file of what the reports will look like. I would like to see if traders would be interested in such a service to help analyze their trading better. The service is not free and TraderDNA charges $100/month. Currently, TraderDNA works with TradeStation, Trading Technologies X_Trader, J-Trader, Interactive Brokers, NinjaTrader, TransAct, CQG Webtrader, and RCG Onyx.

Feedbacks are welcome. Thanks

For more information, visit www.traderdna.com.

[brownsfan019]

James,
Having tried hard to get TraderDNA with OpenECry and watching DNA drop the ball completely, I am very unimpressed with this company and how they conduct business. I think they have an excellent product but when I literally brought them OEC on a platter, they couldn't get the deal done on their end.

And all they had to do was do their job - connect to OEC and off we go.

The worst part was this dragged on for months and made me look like an ass. After I spoke with the DNA rep, it sounded like they knew what they were doing. I soon found out that was not the case. It just seems like the company is all over the place now.

I wonder what has changed since now they are interested in TL again...

Anyways, do not be surprised if you get left hanging.

[darthtrader]

While I think TraderDNA is a great idea it still seems like it would be elementary to knock off yourself.
I've started messing around with something like this in ninja and the only real difference is I would just have to input my entry price/time, exit price/time and stop for each trade. Then sort out stuff in excel.
Seems like a good programmer could knock this off with a web interface in a few hours. Each day throw ES,YM, NQ 1 minute data into flat files, have forms you input entry price/time, exit price/time, stop and a yes no for winner or loser. Calculate the variables, then store it to the persons blog here.