Book Review Bug

[atto]

Besides the uploading image bug (which is known about), I have noticed another small bug on the book reviews. The replies suffer from an off-by-one bug, where the first reply is not labeled, and the second is labeled as Post #1. Besides the different numbering, the first reply does not have a perma-link to it (because it has an index of 0, I'm assuming).

The bug is active on my book review thread here.

[Soultrader]

Hi atto,

Thanks for the notice. These bugs are something I have been trying to fix for quite some time. A few coders have tried to fix this issue but have failed so far. I may have to reconsider a new book review system if I can not fix this. I will keep you posted. Thanks for the notice.

[firewalker]

	Quote:	Soultrader
	Hi atto, Thanks for the notice. These bugs are something I have been trying to fix for quite some time. A few coders have tried to fix this issue but have failed so far. I may have to reconsider a new book review system if I can not fix this. I will keep you posted. Thanks for the notice.

Just thinking out loud... but instead of considering a completely new review system, why not use the default thread functionalities? The post numbering issues would be solved, and you can add some sort of 'poll' to it, where every member who read the book can vote on the various scoring elements ('trading wisdom', 'new insights', 'value for money', etc...). It would have to show not percentages but the average score out of 5.

The first post would still need to contain an image of the book cover or some sort of illustration that clearly identifies the thread as a book review thread instead of an ordinary one.

[Soultrader]

Hello,

This bug has finally been fixed after some serious digging. Thanks for the patience all.