|
Quote: |
|
 |
|
|
As you can observe the whole drawn out debate ending with Db being told to get on his bike is due to the fact that reading buying and selling pressure via smaller time frame is being equated to scalping, this is a fundamental error and as I have said unless one has thoroughly understood the original Wyckoff teaching, it will remained misunderstood. He was not advocating taking positions via tick or 1min chart. If you wish to trade via 15min30min fine, however the smaller time frame allow a micro view into the price action, wave flows in that 15min bar, i.e how many times price knocked at the bottom or the top where it opened , how rapidly it moved to the high or low, how rapidly it was rejected etc, this then allows the trader to better understand the meaning of that 15min open/high/low/close in conjunction with the vol.
|
|
|
|
|
Yes, I fully agree with your statement. Especially in larger bars its helpful to have a look, whats going on in this bar. I have seen several TG chart of the week and they recommended to view on different time frames. I have seen, that they explained someting e.g. in a 10min chart and then switched to a smaller time frame for a more detailed illustration. If one like to switch down to a 1min time frame or even smaller is imho not a question of
VSA or not
VSA. For a better overviev is use the higher time frames, to see more details I go down to a smaller one. It's also a question of the available screenspace.
|
Quote: |
|
|
|
We are all on the same path here, nobody is right or wrong, just different viewpoints and nobody is forcing anybody to adopt one or the other |
|
|
|
|
If I read your post, then I have the impression, that we are quite close on the same path,
VSA and Wyckoff must have some commonalities.