Originally Posted by momentom Re: Exits
Great stuff Walter as I said.
May I offer this comment. As an ex floor trader, my big problem since leaving the floor over 15 years ago is staying in a trade long enough even though I am a scalper. Exiting on the re-entry into the rainbow of the 1 minute chart looks like exiting very early. That's OK if there is a quick re-entry but there is often not. Maybe a little more optimisation could help here.
I tried using ATR stops at first to help me out but looked to the rainbow for a proper solution wanting to remain faithful to your concept.
I then looked at each band according to its colour to try and match the ATR.
My solution so far is an entry into the 6th colour band of the rainbow on the 1 minute chart - CYAN in my case - as my profitable exit. I have only eyeballed this and have not done a proper backtesting - needs some decent programing in MultiCharts.
What do you think? |
Originally Posted by walterw This is a first nice example on how we can optimize our exit definition... I think Momentom you are on the right track here, as it will be able to take more decent profits on a move.. cheers Walter. |
Momentom : I did some more research today on this "exits" issues... I know I need to revisit my exit definition because I find to small the "scalper exit" as previously presented and to large the "traders exit".... looking at your input I find it very valuable... still this 6th band will not be much diferent to the "traders exit" wich is quite long... will work very well under momentum conditions but will give a lot of neutral results under low momentum conditions...
Now Looking more charts today and I did 4 nice trades today

, even made real time videos but they got too large sized lol.. (will now post pictures of the trades) I came to some more interesting exit definition that could be THE EXIT... instead of having various exit alternatives that starts making definitions to complex and go against our
simplicity target...
This new
optimized exit definition could be the bars themselfs crossing the thick darkgreen line...
Below I post the exits of my four trades today all winners...
So this could be a more medium term exit that could promediate my previous two exits definitions into one... Should we call it
"The Exit"
It would be the cross of the bars to the thick Darkgreen line...
these are the small tweaks I was talking about and NO I will just do it on this same thread...

cheers Walter.
PD: Please Remember that this is still an open reasearch process... ALL INPUTS ARE VERY WELCOME...