[walterw]

	Quote:	PYenner
	Ok you got it right but you are also a step ahead. Will do the first step here then come back to the second step. They do overlap yes... The first question is only about how close you want the black line on your VMA indicator to be to a trending price. I tried to show you how it can be so close it gets really mixed in with the price and so far away that it is real smooth. The close one shows detail, but is that what you want to see? Or is it better to have a smoother line that shows trend, but ignores the detail? I don't know which is best yet. I am saying you can chose to have your black base line following either a detailed path like yellow, or a smoother "trendy" path like either blue or magenta. It is something that can be chosen, so think about which ONE of the THREE lines would be best as your black line when there is a trend. It wasn't the best picture. I have seen sometimes when comparing VT to Igorad that sometimes one had a smoother line up between ladder steps, while the other had more wiggles in it, like mini steps on the way up. So do you want mini steps or smooth? I don't have an opinion yet.... would like to hear others. --------------------------- OK, now the second part IS about having multiple VMA lines on a 1 min chart. But that needs to be discussed on its own and it has more to do with the flat bit and the shoulders going into or out of the flat bit. I did post a picture on the other thread that introduced that line of thinking. I want to take it a lot further because it has possibilities. One possiblity is that, in addition to your black line which is flat, you can also have a few more lines, maybe one that works a bit faster so it doesn't stay so flat but it may give you an early warning before your black base line turns up or down into a new trend. That may not be keeping it simple, but it might still be handy. --------------- A third possibilty is replacing the fantail we have now with a fantail of VMA lines. Now there is one scenario where this might give you an exit price guide when trading a recovery. Its too many things to think about, they need to be split up and developed. I suspect a VMA fantail may be more useful than the fantail we have now. Scalping the swings either side of the flat line may also come into it. Dude, it gets all mixed up, overload, meltdown, kablooowweee One at a time, keep it simple, argh, I should be so lucky Pass me a banana someone please...

jejejejej SUPERB POST Pyenner... you are a man after my heart... I also do have this type of brainstorms myself ¡¡¡ awesome ¡¡

I think we have several paralel topics to aboard as you described above...

let me see if I am in sync here...

FIRST TOPIC :

the black line directional movement (could we call it "laddering" ? ) with also the aid of a smaller "turbo vma" telling us some hints of what the blackline will do in front... this could be used for "timing" purposes and the edge relies on the horizontal effect plus the incredible responsivnes on the Cycle/trending stage shift from the vma... so that duo (black line and its turbo) are a complete subject to research on..

SECOND TOPIC :

A Rainbow of base lines ¡¡¡ that is a Terrific topic... I cant say it will outperform our rainbow... but base lines as you mentioned before are doing a "drummond effect" on taking multiple time frames into one chart... what cautivates me on this idea is that the horizontal effect from higher time frames could be plotted on just one time frame and if we take the "turbo" reading from smaller to bigger lines we could have "anticipations" of laddering readings in that particular new rainbow...

so this could be a complete different topic that gradually could merge with the first one.. I like the color of this research... it truly aims to put VMA on steroids...

about simplicity, when original ideas come in there is not a simple plot.... ellaboration at the end of the process takes care of simplifying the last product.. so dont feel intimidated by apparent non simplicity...

keep the ideas flowing ¡¡ I like this one cheers Walter.